The EDH rules committee has issued a ruling that has eliminated “tucking” from EDH. Essentially, cards that would shuffle a commander into the deck give the owner the option of putting the commander back in the command zone, as well as cards that return the card to owner’s hand or place it in the graveyard. So how do we feel about the ruling?
Jason Rice wrote an impassioned piece about the subject and called for essentially the dissolution of the Rules Committee calling them out of touch and calling for the subject of EDH rules to fall under WotC’s purview. It’s a compelling piece and sparked a lot of debate on Reddit.
On the other hand, Sheldon Mennery was a guest on the excellent EDH podcast, The Command Zone. Sheldon does a very good job of defending the committee’s decision and their necessity.
It’s a weird debate and I’m sure you all have an opinion even if your opinion is “I don’t care about EDH, bruh”. Leave it below and let’s get a brouhaha started up in here.