Wake Up and Smell the World!

Are you a Quiet Speculation member?

If not, now is a perfect time to join up! Our powerful tools, breaking-news analysis, and exclusive Discord channel will make sure you stay up to date and ahead of the curve.

It's time, children.  Gather 'round!  I must preface this with a sincere apology - I prefer to do these reviews as the set is spoiled, but if you've been following my Twitter at all, you'll know that last Friday, I grand-opened Dragons Den.  Located in Lafayette, Indiana, it's the town's only dedicated MTG shop, and the public response has been phenomenal.  We had 24 people come out for Sealed Deck on Friday, fired 3 drafts over the weekend, and an 8-man Standard last night.  It's been a great success so far, and as you can imagine, a massive drain on my time.  I've been working with some other editors to keep the site running through all of this, but considering that I am running the store all by myself, my time has been very much under pressure.  Regardless, I've seen enough of the set now to know where I stand on a lot of cards.

Admonition Angel

Large, In Charge, and...Homeless?  She's huge and evasive and packs a hell of a punch, but the main issue is not her size - it's her home.  Most decks that need a massive flier will use a Sphinx or a Baneslayer.  It seems picky, but since her trigger can't nuke lands, there's no guarantee they won't just peel a Terminate and keep on chugging.  If she could really put them out of the game by annihilating lands, she'd be a whole different story.

Archon of Redemption

I don't think anyone is mistaking this card for a Constructed playable, but I could be wrong.  Enjoy the fact that he's a Limited powerhouse and that it's got a picture of a guy riding a lion.  Aces!

Marshal's Anthem

I had one of these with Kor Skyfisher in Sealed Deck.  I won that game.  It could be the right card for a Constructed deck, but its price of $3 is probably correct.  Decks that need them will be highly specific - it lacks the broad spectrum appeal to be anything more than a mid-range rare.  Its power, however, is truly ridiculous.

Stoneforge Mystic

I love everything about this card.  At 1W, she does an awful lot of work.  I'd play this card in the right deck if it only had the "tutor" ability, but the ability to tutor up and play off-color equipment really sweetens the deal.   This might have legs in Extended, where some really good equipment has taken up residence (Sword of Fire and Ice and Light and Shadow!)  In Standard, she fetches out Basilisk Collar, which is one of the more absurd equipments I've seen in a long time.  As with Marshal's Anthem, $3-5 is the most you should expect.

Talus Paladin

Allies might be good, but he's not going to be the reason why.  Bulk Rare, but tradable.

Terra Eternal

See: Talus Paladin.  Replace Allies with Man-Lands.  This needed to cost 1 mana to be any kind of protection against land destruction decks.

Goliath Sphinx

A Goliath waste of a rare.  Clearly just here for Limited, where it ends games faster than a Master of the Wild Hunt activation.

Jace, the Mind Sculptor

[Joke about Bulk Rare Removed due to no one getting it! -kbr]  Jace is already on par with Baneslayer Angel, and the Pro Tour coming up will tell us if that's correct or not.  Local players seem to have a glut of Jaces, which makes me question their lofty price.  If Jace makes a big showing at the top tables of PT San Diego, he'll continue living the Suite Life in his mansion on Park Avenue.  If not, expect a big tumble.  See: Lotus Cobra, which is now selling for $10.   Marquee cards live and die by hype, so if Jace doesn't perform admirably on the biggest stage of the game, expect him to dip.  I may eat my words for this later, but I think $60 is the highest Jace goes until well after Rise of the Eldrazi.  I'd be trading mine away, since there's nowhere left to go but down.

Jwari Shapeshifter

Same issue as many rares in this set; powerful in a niche deck.  If Allies can fix the problem of "we lose to removal", just like a Sliver deck, Shapeshifter will have a home.  Even so, the deck won't be Tier 1 until Rise comes out, if ever.

Quest for Ula's Temple

I can't even get this damned thing to fire off in EDH.  Things I've done in the span of time I waited to get this online:  Hard-cast Tidal Kraken, suspended and resolved Deep-Sea Kraken, paid (30) to manually remove EVERY ice counter from Dark Depths, killed my opponent with aforementioned sea monsters. Bulk rare, untradable, and I'm very bitter about it.

Selective Memory

You can deck yourself with this and a single Treasure Hunt.  Someone, likely of Japanese descent, will break this.  I have neither the time nor inclination to do so in Standard, but I'm sure some nut will.  They're 25 cent rares, and I'll stockpile a few in case the combo deck ever becomes real.  Not gonna make big money here, but it's better than missing out.  MTGO would be the best place to make that trade, since "crap rares" are usually 15 cents and shoot up to $1 when they become relevant.

Thada Adel, Acquisitor

Still not enough good Merfolk to make a Tribal deck, the Acquisitor seems meant for older formats, where she may or may not see any play.  If she does, it will likely not be a 4-of.  Low-end rare, but you can probably trade a few to EDH players, where she's completely insane.

Abyssal Persecutor

As good as advertised, and then some.  This mean son-of-a-bitch packs an ungodly amount of power into 4 mana.  Although the deck itself is questionable at present, the GWB Doran Rock/Junk decks can turn 3 the Demon without much trouble at all.  The drawback, in a fairly large sample of games, was totally irrelevant.  Decks that already play good removal will have the best chance of ignoring the drawback, so resist the temptation to "get cute" with things like Bone Splinters and just admit that you're very happy to Path him to win the game.  $30 seems reasonable given his insane power, and it could slowly creep higher if a deck like Jund decides its time to start Persecuting.  That's a topic for another day, however.  I'm acquiring them as I can, and you ought to be as well.

Agadeem Occultist

Great ability on an 0/2 for 3, which means that he's just another lightning rod in Allies.  If the tribe ever finds a way to protect itself from Wraths and Bolts, it'll be a contender and Occultist will show up in some decks, but until then, it's a true bulk rare.

Anowon, the Ruin Sage

He'll be popular for being a Vampire, and the common "dies to bolt" complaint rings true, but there's a subtle power to Anowon that only really shows up late-game.  If both players are playing off the top of the deck, he can basically lock an opponent out of a game entirely.  You've got to play him as the absolute LAST creature you can to maximize impact, but I watched a match go far south last night when the Vamps player threw down a Ruin Sage and slowly ground the board empty.  Not a high-dollar rare, but not bulk by any means.

Butcher of Malakir

Grave Pact was nice.  5/5 fliers are nice.  Cool cards are nice.  Nice doesn't make cards "good".  Bulk.

Death's Shadow

I'm hesitant to just label this a bulk rare, since it clearly has promise in a deck like SuiBlack.  At 11 life, he's a "bear", and below that, he becomes an actual threat.  In a deck running 8 fetch lands, Vampire Lacerator and Sign in Blood, he MIGHT just be playable.  It seems like a lot of work, but Suicide Black is always a compelling archetype.  Playtesting will show this card's power or lack thereof, but don't write it off just yet.  There might be some gold here.

Kalastria Highborn

A Vampires match came down to Highborn activations last night, with the order of triggers being the difference between a win and a loss.  The card is clearly crucial in the Vamps mirror.  It should stay around $6, but if Vampires becomes a real Tier 1 contender, which it seems to be, it could trend higher.  I like the deck and this card very much, and people are not quick to part with theirs.

Quest for the Nihil Stone

Blech.  I liked this at first, but I cannot make the deck work.  Ben Bleiweiss you were right this time.  My inner Sado-Timmy wants it to work, but alas, it's terrible.  Bulk!

Next time:  Red, Green, Artifacts/Lands and the Gold Cards

Kelly Reid

Founder & Product Manager

View More By Kelly Reid

Posted in Uncategorized

Have you joined the Quiet Speculation Discord?

If you haven't, you're leaving value on the table! Join our community of experts, enthusiasts, entertainers, and educators and enjoy exclusive podcasts, questions asked and answered, trades, sales, and everything else Discord has to offer.

Want to create content with Quiet Speculation?

All you need to succeed is a passion for Magic: The Gathering, and the ability to write coherently. Share your knowledge of MTG and how you leverage it to win games, get value from your cards – or even turn a profit.

8 thoughts on “Wake Up and Smell the World!

  1. Selective Memory: If you're talking short-term, then yes, it won't get above "bulk rare" while it's Standard-legal. But if ANYONE just absolutely BREAKS it in Legacy, I look forward to making my $.50 investments more like $5, if not higher (and if it DOES get broken in Legacy, $5 may not be the potential ceiling price).

    Death's Shadow: I'm getting them for $1 each, and I'm already thinking of casual decks to put him in (most involve either Stuffy Doll + Dead Reckoning, Pandemonium + Suicide, or some combination of both). Praytell, how many cards go from "bulk rare" to "shining PT/GP star" from casual use? (Honest question there: Have there been any cards, especially in recent memory, that have gone from having a casual deck built around it to regular PT/GP Top 8 and the price just shot up like a rocket [at least, relative to its original price]?)

  2. I applaud the article. Although if the next set does turn out to be another "Mirrodin" like it has been rumored, then Stoneforge Mystic is going to be amazing in a white artifact deck! And she will go up in price. I think 2 dollars a piece is a good deal!

  3. The store is at 713 Main St in Lafayette. We're in the downtown area, directly next door to Spurlock's bar/restaurant. Email me if you'd like more info – we're playing Standard tonight at 7pm!

Join the conversation

Want Prices?

Browse thousands of prices with the first and most comprehensive MTG Finance tool around.

Trader Tools lists both buylist and retail prices for every MTG card, going back a decade.