menu

Lessons In Store

Are you a Quiet Speculation member?

If not, now is a perfect time to join up! Our powerful tools, breaking-news analysis, and exclusive Discord channel will make sure you stay up to date and ahead of the curve.

Hey everyone!  It's been a while since I've had a chance to sit down and do some writing for my own site.  As those who follow me on Twitter will know, I've been quite the busy bee lately, having opened my own retail game store.  We focus on Magic: the Gathering right now, with plans to expand to other games once we've got our feet firmly on the ground.  We're called Dragon's Den, located in Lafayette, Indiana (look us up on Facebook!)

I wanted to take a moment to share some insights from the other side of the table, as it were.  I'm hardly pushing the volume a dealer like Star City Games does, but the dynamics of the business are, at their core, very similar.  I allow players to sell me just about any card, and my prices are much more dynamic than the other local stores.  To give you an idea just how dynamic, I don't even own a price gun.  There's no reason to sticker a card when its price could, and does, change daily.  My buy prices reflect the card's current price, my stock of the card, its demand in the local market, and my overall ability to convert it into cash.  Players who trade with, or sell to, the store understand that on a given deal, the house really has to win.  This is because I have overhead expenses, and individual traders do not.  It's funny how many people don't seem to grasp that concept, regardless of the size of the dealer.

I wanted to pop in and deliver a few lessons that every-day traders can learn from some of the methods of a small card shop, which have been derived in part from the operating procedures of the larger dealers.

1) Know your Market/Metagame!  This is a no-brainer, but it bears repeating.  I have not stocked a Vampire Nocturnus for over 3 weeks.  They just disappear and turn into cash as soon as they arrive.  When I'm trading, I go out of my way to snag them.  If someone's reluctant, I will slightly over-pay for them since I know that $0.5x in margin right now is better than $1.0x margin never.  If you're trading for a hot card that you KNOW you can move at high value/profit, don't be afraid to grease a few palms with extra cardboard to get it.  You know buddy Dave is DYING to get an Elspeth, but is the guy trading it to you not sure whether he wants to come off his copy?  Throw in an extra $5 rare, citing the fact that you're willing to give him "more than book value".  This tactic, if it can even be called a tactic, will facilitate many trades.  That $5 rare may never move, rendering its value $0.  Then you turn around and flip Elspeth for a massive profit to your buyer in waiting!

2) Develop good relationships with everyone, and always have some standing offers people can take advantage of.  My unwritten motto in my shop is that if I haven't got it in stock, I'll bust my ass to find you a copy.  I had a customer call me asking for, shockingly, two copies of Elspeth.  I hadn't any.  I also had a customer who had left his collection with me to price out and consider selling.  He had two copies of Elspeth.  Because I had standing offers on the table (I'll find you any card, and I'll always buy your stuff), I was able to make two phone calls and orchestrate a deal.  I didn't make a lot of money on the deal, but I made a couple bucks that I wouldn't have otherwise.  More importantly, both parties now know me as a facilitator, one who will work with them to achieve their goals in Magic.

By maintaining these relationships, many doors you cannot see will open up.  I have had customers tell me that I'm the first person they talk to when they want to sell cards because I always have cash and I'm not picky about what I buy.  Much of what I buy is bulk - commons and uncommons, crap rares, etc, but I have my reasons for picking those up.  What reasons?

3) Bulk is your friend.  There's a reason that every major dealer has a per thousand buy price on bulk cards.  There are a few, actually.  In my neck of the woods, there are a lot of collections that sit around attics for ages.  Most players don't want me to go through 10,000 cards and price them individually, nor have I that kind of time.  They usually bring me a binder and a few 5k count boxes.  I'll price the binder out, then quote them a bulk rate on the box.  The good stuff goes into the display case, and I root through the 5k boxes for any hidden gems, of which there's almost always something!

Since the cost on bulk cards is astoundingly low, it takes very few to make back your investment.  Obviously, finding a Wasteland is the dream, but most often it's the 25c boxes that do my heavy lifting.  Players love these.  There's an air of treasure hunting to digging through the quarter box.  EDH players in particular love that there are cards they may have never seen before.  Selling 8-10 of these pays for a thousand bulk cards, so the margin is high even though the turn-over rate is low.  Still, at absolute worst, smaller shops often sell their bulk to larger dealers who can move the inventory faster.  Thus, everyone along the chain wins.  The end-user gets money for cards they don't want, the small store makes its margin and serves its customers, and the large dealer gets more stock to do with as it sees fit.

Bulk rares are even better.  Most places put bulk rares on buy at $0.10 each, which is what I do as well.   This reflects, once again, the low chance of turning over a given rare.  I throw these rares into the dollar box, so if you do the math, you'll see that once again, my margin is super-high, but mitigated by turn-over rate.  These fixed-price boxes have been wildly successful.

The take-away for the average trader is this: put together a $1 binder!  Tell people you'll trade for bulk rares, or even buy them, at the standard 10 cent rate.  Many people will take you up on this.  Throw those rares into a $1 binder and use that to make up ground whenever a trade is "light" on one end, use them for good-will trades to garner favor amongst friends, and just generally trade them up.  This also goes for current-format Uncommons and Commons.  Many people will give them away, but that's like giving away money.   Have a separate binder or box for them and include them in your trade stock!

In general, the practices that apply to a store apply to a solo trader as well.  You don't have the luxury of a large space to store and display inventory, but there's nothing that says you can't be smart about what you take to tournaments and conventions and trade like a mad-man!

Kelly Reid

Founder & Product Manager

View More By Kelly Reid

Posted in Uncategorized

Have you joined the Quiet Speculation Discord?

If you haven't, you're leaving value on the table! Join our community of experts, enthusiasts, entertainers, and educators and enjoy exclusive podcasts, questions asked and answered, trades, sales, and everything else Discord has to offer.

Want to create content with Quiet Speculation?

All you need to succeed is a passion for Magic: The Gathering, and the ability to write coherently. Share your knowledge of MTG and how you leverage it to win games, get value from your cards – or even turn a profit.

5 thoughts on “Lessons In Store

  1. For a store, this may be a moot point, but is there such a thing as having too many binders? I mean it can be a bit overwhelming when someone ask to trade and then lays out 3 or 4 binders, even if each is a different format/them, or am I over-thinking it?

  2. @jbohnetDrafting is a great way to generate a collection and helps develop you as a player. You get 3 packs worth of cards, the potential to access more than the standard ratio of 1:1 rare to pack (this goes double for uncommons). Additionally it will help develop your skills as a player and deck builder given the nature of the format.When starting and building a collection, its important to understand and pay attention to the financial value of the cards. The best way to do that is with research. This site has a link to the Black Lotus Project and any articles that Kelly writes on Magic Nation usually have insight on the value of cards. Additionally, sites like Star City Games, Channel Fireball and Blackboarder have articles that deal with the art of trading as well as pointers for people starting out. It is also important to have an end goal in mind when you start out. Are you building a collection because you want to trade and make money? Or are you building a collection so that you have a quality pool of cards to draw from when deck building and playing? You need to have an end goal in mind when you start in order to focus your attention and time. For example, if you're attempting to build a card pool for yourself to draw from, you may be whiling to trade even or up to get a card that you're looking for when deck building. The opposite is true when you're attempting to trade for value; you'll want to seek out deals that have people trading up to you.In addition to deciding why you want to build a collection, its important to understand what type of player you are. For example, are you interested in playing kitchen table Magic with your friends or are you interested in attending tournaments? Based on this answer, there are different ways to go about collecting cards. The kitchen table players (typically referred to as Timmy) are going to be better off finding bulk deals to build collections. I'm not suggesting you buy someone's $100 collection off of ebay, but a lot of online stores offer deals for a random assortment of cards which can be helpful in just amassing cards. I would still be cautious with this route as from personal experience, it always more enjoyable to find cards you want and seek them out. If you're interested in playing tournament Magic like a Friday Night Magic event, you should look at the cards in Standard and decide what type of deck you want to build. From there you ought to trade and purchase cards that further you toward completing your deck.The last suggestion is to have patients when playing and starting out. While its tempting to impulsively buy cards with high price tags, if you don't have an understanding of why the card is valuable/powerful/rare, it usually not worth it. If you wait, you'll find good deals when it comes to trading and purchasing cards. You don't have to rush out and buy everything all at once. The best traders are the ones that accumulate cards over time because they'll wait for the best opportunities in order to get the best value out of each transaction. Just some thoughts and best of luck trading and starting out.

  3. If you're going to try and play competitively in Standard (the most common Constructed format), I also recommend buying a full playset (four of each card) of Commons and Uncommons for each new set as it comes out. One of these will usually run you $30-40, and is cheaper than trying to buy many of the cards individually. This is especially true since some Uncommons go way up in price after people figure out their value over the course of a few months.

  4. There are some things I have issues with in your post.1) Not pricing cards because they change constantly is an awful idea. Many cards are stagnant and won't change. To think most cards change daily is an awful idea. I went to a store that had everything priced but underneath the card, it made shopping take a lot of extra time and every time they didn't have one priced they looked it up on SCG, taking a lot of time.2) It is not very efficient to carry around a $1 binder as well. Just something else that might get stolen as well as something that is usually completely unnecessary. I have done my share of dealing since early 2000s and feel I am an expert on trading at events and let m say that the only way to get good at trading and dealing is practice and review what you have done. Writing things down at first or keep a record of starting/ending values of your trade stock is helpful. It is pretty simple and just keeping up on the prices is pretty much it. Anyone else making it appear more complicated clearly don't know how to floor trade correctly…- Stu55

Join the conversation

Want Prices?

Browse thousands of prices with the first and most comprehensive MTG Finance tool around.


Trader Tools lists both buylist and retail prices for every MTG card, going back a decade.