Everything Old Is New Again

Are you a Quiet Speculation member?

If not, now is a perfect time to join up! Our powerful tools, breaking-news analysis, and exclusive Discord channel will make sure you stay up to date and ahead of the curve.

If you're like me, you traded for a Candelabra of Tawnos 6 months ago at $25 and just traded it away at $175. This didn't happen because I predicted the unbanning of Time Spiral and subsequent reemergence of High Tide as a deck. This happened because I play EDH (Commander). Candelabra is a good card that works well in EDH, so I had one when the price spiked. I'm not saying I'm about to make you hundreds of dollars, but there are certain things you should be looking for if you play EDH so that you can reap the benefits of spikes like this.

Before going into further detail, I should also mention that it's almost certain all EDH staples are going to increase in value this summer when both the Commander precon decks and From The Vault: Legends are released. These two products should generate interest in the format, which means demand will increase. Even if you don't pick up anything that has a ridiculous spike, there's still a high likelihood of a lot of these cards gaining value. How much I can't tell you, but most of the things you're looking for are so cheap it's almost impossible to lose money anyway. Here are the categories of cards you should be looking for:

Foil Legendary Creatures - This one is obvious, but it still bears repeating. Legendary creatures are on the rise, and a lot of them are far too inexpensive for how powerful they are as generals (commanders).

Colorless Utility Cards - This is another obvious one, but I don't want people in the comments saying that I ignored either of these groups. Colorless utility cards are the cards that can go in every deck. Many of these have already seen EDH related price hikes, such as Maze of Ith and Sword of Fire and Ice and its brethren. Some already have price hikes to the foils like Mind's Eye, Sculpting Steel, and Oblivion Stone. Finding cheap foil EDH cards is certainly the best investment, but even non-foils have a good chance of gaining value, albeit less dramatically so.

Along these lines, I absolutely recommend picking up Contagion Engine every time you get a chance,  especially foils. This is THE colorless utility card: it wipes an opponent's board, helps you kill people with poison, pumps any of your creatures with +1/+1 counters, and accelerates your planeswalkers. It even has more bizarre and hilarious applications like making Goblin Bomb threatening or Chance Encounter a viable win condition.

Shards Block Foil Mythics - A number of these mythics are legendary creatures, so technically they're already covered. The reason that I'm singling them out, however is the all foil Shards block packs. It's no mystery that the older a card gets, the more its price will rise if it sees continuous demand. Most old cards are worthless, but the cards that have always had demand, such as Sliver Queen and the Darksteel swords, keep going up (no promises as to how quickly). Many of these mythic rares will see continuous demand because they're great for EDH, be they generals or otherwise. Most of these mythics are also grotesquely undervalued because of the glut of foils resulting from the ill-conceived Shards block foil packs. Kresh, the Bloodbraided foil can be picked up for about $3 pretty easily. Considering that this is one of the easiest generals to kill someone with in a single hit, that's pretty strange. You can get Maelstrom Nexus for about the same price, and that's a must-have for every five color EDH deck ever. There are still foil Shards block packs available because the demand for the packs was so low (which, if you're reading, Wizards, was only because of the price) but once the influx of new supply dries up, we'll see the price rise. I expect some of these cards to have dramatic increases.

Cards With Off-Color Abilities - People enjoy playing mono-coloured EDH decks for a number of reasons. You'll never get colour screwed, you don't have to spend money on expensive mana bases, and you get access to powerful cards like Extraplanar Lens and the [card Sapphire Medallion]Tempest medallions[/card]. Every color has its weakness, however, because of the colour pie. Of course, the colour pie has changed multiple times, and Wizards used to frequently prints off-color cards.

Have you ever lost a game to Sword of Light and Shadow because your mono-black deck can't destroy artifacts?

Well a card that has seen a recent price spike from mere pennies to multiple dollars, Gate to Phyrexia, can keep that from happening. These cards are very limited in how much they can raise in price because they're normally very specific and often underpowered cards, but any profit is good. Oh, and making your deck better is good too.

Cards With Obviously Powerful Abilities That Nobody Cares About- And here we have it. This is where you have the chance to make real money, if you get lucky. Candelabra was a blatantly powerful card. In a format like EDH where lands [card Miraris Wake]never tap for a single mana[/card], Candelabra was like a 1 mana Mirari's Wake. Eureka has an enormously powerful ability that was great for multiplayer fun. And I'm not even going to get started on how many stupid applications Power Artifact has. Now many of these cards that no one cards about, cards like Karmic Justice, Mana Reflection, and Hunting Grounds are unlikely to ever have tournament applications. Flip through your binders though or search through old sets on gatherer to find more cards with ridiculous abilities. If they're affordable and have EDH applications, there's a good chance you'll see them rise at least a little bit. And if you get really lucky, you may have just accidentally bought the next big legacy card.

8 thoughts on “Everything Old Is New Again

  1. Nice article!

    You hit on a great point at the end there. I make a lot of money by trading for "bulk" rares with insane abilities then trading them to the EDH crown as "Dollar" rares. May not seem like much but taking a 10 cent card and turning it in to a $1 card is a 1000% return.

    1. trading $0.10 rares to EDH players at $1 was the old awesome secret to EDH trading/ The new secret? Most of those $0.10 cards are now worth $2-$3!

  2. I think the problem is if you have never played it at all it is hard to really know what cards they play with. I mean ya some obvious choices exist but beyond that??? So picking up bulk is fine but if you are going to invest in foils that is more difficult.

  3. I play the game a lot but I do not have any desire to play EDH because I am unlucky as it is and hoping for 1s over and over is a horrible type imo. I simply don't like the format but there is no reason I shouldn't make some money from everyone else's love for it.

    1. There absolutely is a reason you shouldn't make money from everyone else's love of EDH: you don't want to put the work in. You don't want to play the format, and you don't know what cards people play with which means you haven't done even the most cursory research into the format. You can make money off of it, but not if you just sit on your ass and wait for someone to tell you what to do.

  4. Something like Power Artifact sells for around 25 right now. Do you think it could still go up in value, or do you imagine that this is what it's going to be.

  5. Listen "angry magic guy". I may seem like the usual magic player to you but I won't sit behind my computer and talk shit because you want to be an ass. First of all I pay for content on a Magic financial sight (which I believe you write articles on) so ya I can make money off of something, anything fo that matter that I want. I don't love Yugioh actually I hate it but I make money of it. So you can kiss my ass. Now back to the beginning of what I said you can act bad ass and talk shit behind a computer I'm in Spartanburg SC. Let me know when you are around I'll come have a conversation with you about what I can and can't do in PERSON. See how angry and bad ass you act then.

  6. I play multiple formats but because you love a format that I don't you wanna act like you are better than me. You aren't and if I want to make money from that format that is my business. You don't have to give me any info. You also don't have to write articles about making money on Magic but you do.

Join the conversation

Want Prices?

Browse thousands of prices with the first and most comprehensive MTG Finance tool around.

Trader Tools lists both buylist and retail prices for every MTG card, going back a decade.