Insider: All Good Things…

Are you a Quiet Speculation member?

If not, now is a perfect time to join up! Our powerful tools, breaking-news analysis, and exclusive Discord channel will make sure you stay up to date and ahead of the curve.

The best came last.

Much like the vaunted epic conclusion to the Star Trek: Next Generation franchise, there comes a time in everyone’s life when they need to set their priorities straight, or look at their hobbies and investments in a different way if we intend to grow as people. This article won’t follow the traditional style because I won’t be telling you what cards to pick up. Instead, we’ll be looking at when to fold and either get out, or start anew.

Probably not what you were expecting to read from a site that normally advocates buying and trading, but quite possibly one of the more important things that you’ve had to ask yourself: “Is Magic the Gathering holding me back from achieving what I want out of life?”

It sickens me to say this, but sometimes when I look at my collection, I’m just disgusted with myself. If you’re like me, you’ve got thousands of dollars wrapped up in this game even though you can only ever play one deck at a time.

But, between traders, having a cash pool to draw upon, our own “personal stash” of expensive cards, and the need to build decks of every format, it’s easy to lose sight of the fact that sometimes, more is not better, and the money we have wrapped up in cards could be better used elsewhere.

As a personal example, I don’t have much debt aside from a mortgage, but I do have a little bit on my credit card. I say a “little bit”, but what I mean is close to $4000. Not a lot in this day and age, but enough to make you think about it whenever a bill comes and it shows that your minimum payment is equal to the cost of a box of Innistrad. Yes, some of it may pay down the principle, but how can I justify losing that much money every month when I could easily liquidate a few of my Magic card assets to pay it off?

A Rock and a Hard Place

The thing is, we invest so much of our time into our image as Magic players that considering selling off a portion of our collections is sometimes akin to selling off a part of our identities. I’ve become attached to the cards I have, even those that I don’t use.

My [card Candelabra of Tawmos]Candelabras[/card] and playset+ of dual lands happily stare back at me whenever I crack my “good stuff” binder, and my friends “oooh” and “awww” about the beauty they see within it.

I like that feeling. I like it when someone says to me: “Dude, that is a SICK collection you have there!”

These statements reaffirm that, when it comes to my hobby, I am doing well and have whatever kind of respect and awe you get from other players who want to achieve the kind of success that I/we have.

Letting go of these small pieces of ourselves is not as easy as just one day saying “screw it” and listing all our wares on eBay. Like a cigarette smoker with an addiction, it’s not that easy to quit.

It's All Your Fault!

You may be saying to yourself: “Well Carl, you’re the one who got yourself into this situation, you shouldn’t have overspent on cards!”

That’s the thing… who says I racked up that debt because of Magic cards?

In my case it was incidentals with my near hundred year old house that forced me to liquidate my savings and use credit to keep it together. Everyone has their own story, and if you don’t right now, good for you! But one day you may, and when that day comes and you need balance the need for cash versus credit, I hope you remember this article.

Going back to my house story, I could have just as easily sold off a few of my things that had value instead of racking up debt, but I don’t see my stuff as worth dollars and cents… I see them as a lifeline to my hobbies. Precious memories or good times yet to be had.

The fact remains that, even after I accumulated debt, I could still have slowly sold things to pay it down. Instead I acted irresponsibly and let my lust for accumulating more and more stuff hold me back from paying down debt and moving on with my life as a clean slate.

It's a Trick! Get an Axe!

Classic Ash!

Personally, I like to fool myself into believing that by investing in more cards, or trading into better, more valuable cards, that I’m "making money".

Well, little brain, that is simply not the case.

True, you may be increasing the value of your portfolio, but until you actually sell something, all you have is a stack of cardboard with a somewhat ambiguous value to a small group of like-minded collectors.

You can’t go to a store and give them a Birthing Pod for a bag of milk (and no, telling them "It’s going to go up in value because of a new mechanic in Dark Ascension!" is not going to make them think you’re any less crazy).

In fact, I’d go so far as to actually say that unless you’re Jon Medina and if you’re in my situation, it’s actually costing you MORE because of the illusion of gains that you’re under. Sure, you made $10 in REAL cash every FNM’s this month… too bad that at 15%, that $4000 debt is costing you roughly $50/month in interest, so you’re still out at least $10 overall. Not only that, but when you make a small profit like that, what are you more likely to do:

1) Put $10 on your credit card/against debt?


2) Go out to the pub with the boys after the tournament, spend it on a pitcher and say: “This beer is FREE because I paid for it in Magic profits!”

… See where I’m coming from?

If you have debt, the pitcher wasn’t free. And on top of that you’ve deluded yourself into possibly spending more that you would have in the first place because now you can buy a second pitcher with the $10 you’d brought from home with the intention of spending regardless of whether or not you’d sold anything.

Buying a Collection = Buying Debt?

Buying collections is one of the BEST ways to actually make money at this game, since the discounts on an entire lot are often quite deep.

But where does that cash come from, and where does it go once you’ve made it back?

If you’re using credit to fund your expenditures because it’s "too good a deal to pass up", then instead of paying back your "loan" you spend the money on more cards or other things. Did you profit at all? Or did you just create more debt for yourself?

Us silly North Americans in particular just love to accumulate debt because it’s accepted here for some reason or another and considered the norm. It’s why I said that I "only" have $4000 in debt, because when I compare it to others it seems almost trivial.

We have to look at our buying strategies to avoid these kinds of pitfalls in order to stop the debt cycle and make real profit. If you can’t afford to lose the money and you don’t have the money in the first place, maybe you should re-evaluate going all in on the debt machine that we create for ourselves and instead just think to yourself: “I am making money by not spending money”.

The Big Trade Off

Time is finite. Each of us is granted a certain amount. And when it’s gone, it’s gone.

Time is a form of currency, and that currency is your life. The more you invest in cards at the expense of other things is a trade that you are directly making. Go to the movies with your girl/boyfriend, or buy a few packs of Scars of Alara? If you’re on a fixed income or limited budget, these are the choices that you’re making whenever you make a purchase.

Granted, this principle can be applied to anything we chose to spend our hard earned wages on, but, really, I’m sure I’m not the only one who spends a decent amount of my disposable income on cards. Speculating or not, I can’t spend that money twice… unless I use credit, as we’ve already discussed.

I have a friend on a fixed income who told me they were going to pay their rent ahead of time for the next two months so that when they get their next cheque, they could spend it all on Magic without thought of consequences since their living arrangements will already be covered.

This made me really sad for him, as he is trading in so much of his life and time into this game at the sacrifice of being able to do anything else. Please don’t let this happen to you.

Go out and enjoy life while you’re able and keep your hobby a (profitable and fun!) hobby, not a complete lifestyle.

Where Do We Go From Here?

I’m not advocating for you to sell your collection, as I know that I personally could never do that.

All I’m saying is that if you have debt and look at Magic cards as an investment, maybe you should ask yourself how much are you actually making versus losing to the banks? How many other things that you wanted to do with your life are you sacrificing in order to feed your obsession?

Maybe now's the time to cash in on some of those cards and pay off your debt. This doesn't mean you have to sell of your collection, but remember that your collection is liquid and it is okay to tap into that stream once in a while. Especially when you can buy down any interest you're paying elsewhere.

Let’s talk turkey here. You’re obviously looking to profit if you have a subscription to this site. That’s why we exist: to make you money. But sometimes the best way to actually make real gains is to pay down what you already owe, or go on that vacation with your family while you’re still young enough to enjoy it rather than buy those last two pieces of the P9 that you’re missing.

Think about that: What if you could say that Magic has paid for a vacation with your family or friends?

Give and take. Life is a delicate balance, one that’s easy to lose sight of and hard to bring back to equilibrium.

Maybe when you reeaalllyyy think about it, you do only need one deck of each format right now and you could sell the rest to clear up debt in order to start over with a clean slate with none of the stress and sleepless nights that owing creditors goes hand in hand with.

Maybe I don’t really need those three Candelabras for the "just in case", because maybe now is that just in case? Or maybe I should wait until next pay check to purchase that beat up beta Demonic Tutor they’ve got eyeing you from that expensive leather-bound binder.

Maybe you have no debt at all and this article didn't speak to you. But maybe you do have debt and this will inspire you to use your hobby to clear those stresses away.

And maybe this has helped you more than any hot pickup ever could. Even so, there are four other articles put out on this site weekly that keep you queued in. 🙂

On a Personal Note…

This is unfortunately the last article I will be writing in the near future for Quiet Speculation due to some health issues I’ve been having lately. I’ve got to turn my attention to focusing on getting better. And while I absolutely love writing, I feel that I need to prioritize where my time is going to go for now.

While I will still certainly try and make it out to FNM’s whenever I can and submit the occasional article, time and health permitting, I’m going to have to step down for a while and recover both physically and mentally. It has been a true pleasure getting to meet the QS crew and all of you Insiders. You’ve taught me as much as I’ve taught you and I thank you for all the opportunities and kind words.

Keep it real friends. Enjoy your lives AND your hobbies. Remember your priorities. And remember to have fun. 🙂

Carl Szalich

Editor's Note: We will miss Carl's constant enthusiasm and weekly contribution. I know that I have really enjoyed working along side him and learning all that he has had to teach. It is with hope and confidence that we all look forward to Carl's eminent return.

So thank you, Carl, for everything you've done. Rest up, don't worry about the Dark Ascension spoilers, and remember that you're still fully part of the QS family.

-Tyler Tyssedal

Carl Szalich

Currently found ranching Orggs in the wilds of London, Ontario, Canada, I've been playing MTG for the past 15 years. I remember when trading Dual Lands for Craw Wurms was the "in thing to do", and Shivan Dragon fought Royal Assassin to see which would carry the higher price tag. I'm primarily interested in MTG finance, and like a good Icatian Moneychanger I believe that we are all "bigger than we think" when it come to what we have, and what our potential may be.

View More By Carl Szalich

Posted in Finance, Free InsiderTagged , ,

Have you joined the Quiet Speculation Discord?

If you haven't, you're leaving value on the table! Join our community of experts, enthusiasts, entertainers, and educators and enjoy exclusive podcasts, questions asked and answered, trades, sales, and everything else Discord has to offer.

Want to create content with Quiet Speculation?

All you need to succeed is a passion for Magic: The Gathering, and the ability to write coherently. Share your knowledge of MTG and how you leverage it to win games, get value from your cards – or even turn a profit.

6 thoughts on “Insider: All Good Things…

  1. This is without a doubt one of the best, most useful articles I have ever read on here. You're spot-on in everything you said here, and I hope this helps some readers who might be in a similar situation.
    My personal experience with debt is that I was introduced to the work of personal finance guru Dave Ramsey in high school and learned to live a certain way. As a result, I am proud to be debt-free. It's not easy, but I promise that driving used cars and saving to pay for things in cash is worth it at the end of the month when your money is not on its way out to someone else.
    On a different note, I've enjoyed all your work and wish you a quick recovery. Already looking forward to reading your work again.

  2. Impressive.

    Hope you feel better soon Carl!

    Only continuous debt I have is a mortgage (which was unavoidable) so I cannot really relate to the whole being in debt thing as much as some (actually being in debt is not really an accepted thing in these parts, other than the mortgage that is). I can relate to the parting with cards being a problem or choosing to buy a card rather than something else that you know might have been a better idea or even instead of saving the money for a rainy day. I know one reason I still don't have a car is that I save less than I could (though I would like Corbin go for a used one and pay it off right away).

    Anyway, let me repeat myself, a really good piece and hope your recovery is quick!

  3. This article was written very well and communicated a key point often overlooked. It resonated with me 100%. I often consider the opportunity cost of having a valuable collection. There are many days I look at my valuable cards and wonder if I am truly getting my money’s worth from them, or if I could benefit from having the cash for that family vacation instead. It’s a very difficult balance.

    The fact that we even consider this balance, however, is a huge point in our favor. It means this hobby hasn’t become our lifestyle. We can still live our lives outside of this game. That must count for something, right?

    You will be missed while you are on sabbatical, and I wish you a speedy recovery. Best of luck!

  4. Good health to you, Carl. Thanks for the article, I've read it carefully and bookmarked it so I can look back some times later, to reconsider my priorities in life.

  5. Just wanted to say thanks to everyone who has wished me well on my recovery :*). I’m already starting to feel a little better, and was even able to make it to FNM last night!

    About the article, it is indeed a very personal piece, and as Sigmund mentioned the opportunity costs of having the kinds of collections we do sometimes need to be looked at and reevaluated. Not just from a cash perspective, but from a time investment point of view as well. I’m really glad that some of you have taken it to heart, because I know that even I read it over a few more times since having it published and really thought hard about where I am with the game. If nothing else, I hope it has at least added a little more perspective to how we live our lives, magic related or not.

Join the conversation

Want Prices?

Browse thousands of prices with the first and most comprehensive MTG Finance tool around.

Trader Tools lists both buylist and retail prices for every MTG card, going back a decade.

Quiet Speculation