menu

Insider: A Look at Supplemental Products

Are you a Quiet Speculation member?

If not, now is a perfect time to join up! Our powerful tools, breaking-news analysis, and exclusive Discord channel will make sure you stay up to date and ahead of the curve.

Welcome back, readers!

While everyone is aware that WoTC has created a lot of supplemental products over Magic's lifespan, many might not know all of them nor the value they contain. Today we'll take a comprehensive look at all the supplemental products.

For most competitive players, supplemental products are more of a "sideshow." The print runs are nowhere near as large as a Standard-legal set, and rarely do any of the cards truly break into the competitive scene. That said, they can contain valuable tournament staples (Flusterstorm), splashy cards with high casual appeal (The Mimeoplasm), and ultra-rare collector's items (Zodiac Dragon).

Rivals Quick Start Set

For the first supplemental products we have to jump all the way back to 1996. That year Wizards printed the Rivals Quick Start Set, though this particular product didn't have any actual new cards in it (just reprints). These can be identified by the 1996 copyright at the bottom. I looked at both TCG Player and Star City Games and neither lists this variant of card. I'm not sure how valuable they are, but if you run into any while sorting through bulk, I'd suggest you separate them out.

scathe zombies

Portal

Next up we have the Portal set released in 1997. I don't recall this one being all that popular. Most of the rares were underwhelming, or slightly worse versions of existing cards in the Standard-legal realm (like the different tutors, which are now popular thanks to Commander).





There were even a few rares that were just up-shifted uncommons from previous sets, like Summer Bloom, Phantom Warrior, and Pyroclasm. Some of the reprints are more valuable simply due to the different artwork. In addition to being an old set, this one was pretty unpopular at the time (I know my play group didn't like it and we were the target audience), so supply is pretty limited.

Portal: Second Age

This set was released in 1998, following the footsteps of its older brother. There are only two notable cards from this set that have any real value today (and again it's due to Commander demand).



For the dragon collectors out there, this is another card of note:


Portal: Three Kingdoms

This version of Portal wasn't released in the US. This set was designed for the Asian market which involved some specific design aspects (for example, there are no skeletons). The set had a lot of functional or near-functional reprints of pre-existing cards like Capture of Jingzhou, which makes them incredibly desirable for Commander players. It's also important to note that English versions were only sold in Australia and New Zealand and are very rare (hence the price tag for many of these cards). The most valuable is of course a tutor (though it has had a judge reprint recently).






Starter 1999

This was the third attempt by WoTC to introduce a nice introductory product to help make the rules easier to understand for players. Again WoTC introduced some new cards that have found a home in eternal formats, though in this case there were two that actually made it into Legacy.



Starter 2000

The last big attempt at getting new players into the game, Starter 2000 had only two rares Vizzerdrix and Trained Orgg. There is absolutely no money in the set, as it was little more than a smaller print run of all existing cards with the original artwork. The best way to differentiate these from other printings is the copyright date at the bottom. Starter 2000 cards say "1993-2000 Wizards of the Coast" at the bottom.

MonsGoblin Raiders

Unglued

The first of two humorous expansions from WoTC. Unglued introduced the first full-art lands, which as we've seen have enamored players over the years. These are some of the most valuable cards in the set. The cards aren't legal in any sanctioned format (as they have silver borders) but a few of the more powerful ones are still collected by some players.



Unhinged

The second of the two humorous expansions from WoTC (printed in 2004). Unhinged had the added benefit of including foils. WoTC again included full-art lands with even more of the artwork showing, and (though I admit this is my personal opinion) they're still some of the most beautiful cards in Magic.

Many of the foil rares have retained value (again nothing in the set is legal in any sanctioned format) and the most valuable card in the set is a foil rare:


Anthologies

This was a compilation set (basically reprints from previous sets) released in 1998. It was similar to Chronicles in that it included white borders, despite the fact that the cards included kept their original set symbol.

GoblinOffensive

The most valuable card in the set is the Pendelhaven:

Pendelhaven

Battle Royale

This boxed set was released to encourage more multiplayer Magic. Similar to Anthologies, the Battle Royale set also included white borders and the color-coded rarity symbols (even for the sets that didn't originally have them, though interestingly enough if the original printing had no set symbol then none was added). The most valuable cards in the set are:

LandTax Reanimate SpikeWeaver

Beatdown Box Set

Here we have the first boxed set made up entirely of reprints that got its own set symbol (a mace). Interestingly enough, there are no white cards in the set (it was made up of two decks and neither included white). The most valuable card in the set is actually Lightning Bolt.

LightningBolt

Deckmasters

This compilation set was created out of a challenge match between Richard Garfield (the game's creator) and Jon Finkel (arguably the best player to ever play the game). They were told to create decks using only Ice Age and Alliances, were only allowed four total rares, and were not allowed more than two copies of any given card.

This boxed set included four foil cards (Icy Manipulator, Incinerate, Lhurgoyf, and Necropotence). Necro is the most expensive card in the set, and the only foil version with the original artwork.

necro

Duels of the Planeswalkers

These decks were released back in 2010 to coincide with the release of the game by the same name, again intended as an introductory product. While there aren't a lot of cards worth money in this set, there are two outliers:

vigor coat of arms

Duel Decks

dd dvd

Since 2007, WoTC has released at least one Duel Deck product every year. Each is a set of two decks meant to be played against each other, consisting of reprints and alternate-art foils. For the first two years they released one Duel Deck per year, but since then have been releasing two per year.

Duel Deck Release Date Notable Cards
Elves vs. Goblins 11/16/07 Imperious Prefect, Allosaurus Rider, Wirewood Lodge, Goblin Ringleader
Jace vs. Chandra 11/07/08 Counterspell, Terrain Generator, Jace Beleren, Chandra Nalaar
Divine vs. Demonic 04/10/09 Akroma, Angel of Wrath, Demonic Tutor
Garruk vs. Liliana 10/30/09 Garruk Wildspeaker, Liliana Vess, Rancor
Phrexia vs. The Coaltion 04/19/10 Phyrexian Arena
Elspeth vs. Tezzeret 09/03/10 Elspeth, Knight-Errant; Tezzeret the Seeker; Swords to Plowshares
Knights vs. Dragons 04/01/11 Knight of the Reliquary, Dragonspeaker Shaman, Knight of the White Orchid
Ajani vs. Nicol Bolas 09/02/11 Ajani Vengeant; Nicol Bolas, Planeswalker; Lightning Helix; Countersquall
Venser vs. Koth 04/30/12 Venser, the Sojourner; Path to Exile; Steel of the Godhead; Preordain; Koth of the Hammer
Izzet vs. Golgari 09/07/12 Niv-Mizzet, the Firemind; Golgari Grave-Troll
Sorin vs. Tibalt 04/15/13 Sorin, Lord of Innistrad; Wall of Omens; Tibalt, the Fiend-Blooded
Heroes vs. Monsters 09/06/13 Sun Titan, Beast Within
Jace vs. Vraska 04/14/14 Jace, Architect of Thought; Vraska the Unseen
Speed vs. Cunning 09/05/14 Krenko, Mob Boss
Elspeth vs. Kiora 02/27/15 Elspeth, Sun's Champion
Zendikar vs. Eldrazi 08/28/15 Avenger of Zendikar, Eldrazi Temple
Blessed vs. Cursed 02/26/16 Geist of Saint Traft, Mindwrack Demon, Gravecrawler
Nissa vs. Ob Nixilis 09/02/16 Nissa, Voice of Zendikar; Ob Nixilis Reignited

Here we can see that the variance is often pretty high with regards to the value contained within. One of the most obvious points is that the ones that include planeswalkers in the titles tend to have a bit more value, if only because the planeswalker cards themselves always retain casual appeal.

From the Vault

MTG_V10_BoxSet

The From the Vault (FTV) series was WoTC's way to "give back" to game stores by providing them with a highly desirable limited-print-run product at a low MSRP. Stores were free to purchase them as the low wholesale prices and sell them for whatever they wanted. These sets are usually chock full of value with staples across all different formats.

FTV Deck Release Date Notable Cards
Dragons 08/29/08 Nicol Bolas; Hellkite Overlord; Kokusho, the Evening Star
Exiled 08/28/09 Berserk, Lotus Petal, Necropotence, Sensei's Divining Top, Strip Mine, Trinisphere
Relics 08/27/10 Aether Vial, Memory Jar, Mox Diamond, Sol Ring, Sword of Body and Mind
Legends 08/26/11 Kiki-Jiki, Mirror Breaker; Ulamog, the Infinite Gyre, Teferi, Mage of Zhalfir, Progenitus
Realms 08/31/12 Ancient Tomb; Grove of the Burnwillows; Maze of Ith; Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth, Vesuva
Twenty 08/23/13 Gilded Lotus; Green Sun's Zenith; Jace, the Mind Sculptor; Thran Dynamo; Venser, Shaper Savant
Annihilation 08/22/14 Burning of Xinye, Rolling Earthquake, Smokestack, Terminus, Wrath of God
Angels 08/21/15 Akroma, Angel of Fury; Akroma, Angel of Wrath; Avacyn, Angel of Hope; Baneslayer Angel, Entreat the Angels, Iona, Shield of Emeria, Platinum Angel
Lore 08/19/16 Dark Depths, Umezawa's Jitte, Unmask

Note that these products were only available to game stores (not big-box stores), and each store got a specific number. Thus the older ones are rarer than the newer ones (due to there being more game stores now than back in 2008).

Premium Deck Series

pds slivers

The Premium Deck Series was a relatively short-lived series that ran from 2009 to 2011 and encompassed three releases. These decks were all foil, but the foiling process was different than pack foils and they feel different than regular foils. Each one contained one very noteworthy card at the time of its printing.

Premium Deck Notable Cards
Slivers Sliver Overlord
Fire and Lightning Chain Lightning
Graveborn Entomb

Planechase

planechase

Planechase is a game variant created by WoTC that involves playing Magic on different planes, which introduce some sort of effect and are randomly chosen. The game begins on a plane and then players are allowed to try and planeswalk away by rolling dice. There were two sets of Planechase products—one in 2009 and one in 2012, with each set sold as mini-decks.

Planechase Set Deck Name Notable Cards
2009 Elemental Thunder Explosive Vegetation
2009 Metallic Dreams Master of Etherium
2009 Strike Force Lightning Helix
2009 Zombie Empire Grave Pact
2012 Chaos Reigns Maelstrom Wanderer, Shardless Agent, Beast Within, Bloodbraid Elf
2012 Night of the Ninja Sakishim'a Student, Vela the Night-Clad, Quietus Spike
2012 Primordial Hunger Preyseizer Dragon; Dragonlair Spider; Thromok, the Insantiable
2012 Savage Auras Kor Spiritdancer, Ghostly Prison, Krond the Dawn-Clad

The key takeaways here are that the 2012 versions had more desirable and valuable cards in them than the original 2009 decks. The planes were also only available by getting each deck.

Archenemy

This was another WoTC-created game variant. In this multiplayer variant, one player is the "archenemy" who gets the help of the "scheme" cards that came with the decks you could purchase (though you could play any deck you wanted). This was similar to the previously mentioned Planechase products in which certain schemes came with each deck, so in order to get them all you had to buy all four decks.

Deck Name Notable Cards
Assemble the Doomsday Machine Duplicant, Sundering Titan, Lightning Greaves
Trample Civilization Underfoot Mosswort Bridge; Path to Exile; Kamahl, Fist of Krosa
Scorch the World with Dragonfire Dragonspeaker Shaman, Thran Dynamo
Bring About the Undead Apocalypse Reanimate, Beacon of Unrest, Cemetery Reaper, Terminate

Commander

Of course I couldn't write this article without discussing the Commander product, which was originally released in 2011. This product also changed the name of the format from EDH (Elder Dragon Highlander) to Commander. It's important to note that the Commander format really seemed to take off after 2011, so there are a lot of notable cards in the first five decks. Many haven't been reprinted, and the first crop of decks weren't as mass-printed as now (though they were all available at big-box stores for a while).

Commander Set Deck Name Notable Cards
Commander Heavenly Inferno Kaalia of the Vast; Path to Exile; Akroma, Angel of Fury; Mana-Charged Dragon
Commander Mirror Mastery Riku of Two Reflections; Animar, Soul of Elements; Garruk Wildspeaker
Commander Counterpunch Ghave, Guru of Spores; Karador, Ghost Chieftain; Scavenging Ooze
Commander Political Puppets Zedruu the Greathearted; Flusterstorm; Chaos Warp; Martyr's Bond
Commander Devour for Power The Mimeoplasm; Damia, Sage of Stone; Skullbriar, the Walking Grave; Riddlekeeper
Commander 2013 Evasive Maneuvers Thousand-Year Elixir; Karmic Guide
Commander 2013 Eternal Bargain Oloro, Ageless Ascetic; Thoptor Foundry; Toxic Deluge
Commander 2013 Mind Seize True-Name Nemesis;
Commander 2013 Power Hungry Primal Vigor
Commander 2013 Nature of the Beast Avenger of Zendikar; Tempt with Discovery
Commander 2014 Forged in Stone Containment Priest; Nahiri, the Lithomancer
Commander 2014 Peer Through Time Teferi, Temporal Archmage; Cyclonic Rift
Commander 2014 Sworn to Darkness Ob Nixilis of the Black Oath; Ghoulcaller Gisa
Commander 2014 Built from Scratch Wurmcoil Engine; Goblin Welder; Caged Sun
Commander 2014 Guided by Nature Freyalise, Llanowar's Fury; Titania Protector of Argoth;
Commander 2015 Call the Spirits Karlov of the Ghost Council; Phyrexian Arena; Karmic Justice
Commander 2015 Seize Control Mystic Confluence
Commander 2015 Plunder the Graves Meren of Clan Nel Toth; Eternal Witness; Eldrazi Monument; Skullclamp
Commander 2015 Wade into Battle Gisela, Blade of Goldnight; Urza's Incubator; Blade of Selves
Commander 2015 Swell the Host Ezuri, Claw of Progress; Arachnogenesis
Commander 2016 Entropic Uprising Chromatic Lantern; Vial Smasher the Fierce
Commander 2016 Open Hostility Skullclamp
Commander 2016 Stalwart Unity Tempt with Discovery; Collective Voyage
Commander 2016 Breed Lethality Atraxa, Praetors' Voice; Kalonian Hydra; Crystalline Crawler
Commander 2016 Invent Superiority Breya, Etherium Shaper; Skullclamp; Magus of the Will

Commander's Arsenal

Reading above you may notice that there was no Commander 2012 set of decks. In 2012 WoTC created the Commander's Arsenal product, which was basically like an FTV but aimed at Commander players. Commander's Arsenal consisted of 18 foil cards (again with a non-standard foiling process). These 18 cards were:

  • Chaos Warp
  • Command Tower
  • Desertion
  • Diaochan, Artful Beauty
  • Dragonlair Spider
  • Decree of Pain
  • Duplicant
  • Edric, Spymaster of Trest
  • Kaalia of the Vast
  • Loyal Retainers
  • Maelstrom Wanderer
  • Mind's Eye
  • Mirari's Wake
  • The Mimeoplasm
  • Rhystic Study
  • Scroll Rack
  • Sylvan Library
  • Vela the Night-Clad

It also came with some oversized foil cards, including a few on the Reserved List (because they were oversized, WoTC felt it didn't violate the spirit of the Reserved List). These oversized cards were;:

  • Sliver Queen
  • Karrthus, Tyrant of Jund
  • Mayael the Anima
  • Zur the Enchanter
  • Grimgrin, Corpse-Born
  • Brion Stoutarm
  • Glissa, the Traitor
  • Godo, Bandit Warlord
  • Azusa, Lost but Seeking
  • Karn, Silver Golem

Conclusion

And there you have an extensive list of all supplemental products including new cards, or a different visual treatment (borders, set symbols, etc.). WoTC has produced other supplemental product like the Holiday gift boxes, but those were just bundles of Standard-legal packs and some additional packaging. I hope you enjoyed this deep dive into the different types of supplemental products WoTC has offered throughout the years.

6 thoughts on “Insider: A Look at Supplemental Products

  1. (Internationa) Collectors Edition could very well be considered the first supplemental product, the Rivals set did bring us the first preconstructed decks. The Scathe Zombies shown is not actually from the Rivals set: the Rivals set has a 1995 copyright date and a small misprint on the back that distinguishes the cards from regular 4th. Instead it’s from the Introductory Two-Player Set, which did have a 1996 copyright date and it could be from either the Dutch or English version of that set. In The Netherlands you get them very often in collections and they tend not to be valued over their 4th counterparts.

    Anthologies holds many misprints, like the 2/2 Common Mirri. This might’ve been nice to include.

    Due to the formatting of the tables every time the “notable cards” go over 2 lines it becomes a bit unclear which cards belong to which product. I first thought Berserk was listed as part of FTV: Dragons.

    Don’t forget the World Championship Decks as other supplemental product.

    1. pi, I wholeheartedly agree with the tables thing. I don’t like how wordpress does tables (especially since I tend to use them a lot), however, I still love how much information tables can convey in a structured manner that is still relatively concise.

      You have a valid point about the IE/CE sets and World Championship decks, however, while writing this I wanted to stick to cards that were legal in some tournament level formats and while I know that Unhinged/Unglued, are not, they were draftable when they came out so I left them in.

      There’s definitely a lot of additional products that could be discussed in any future article (Pins, Playing cards, the original computer games, etc.)

  2. Great article! Very informative. There were a couple things I think were overlooked:

    Duel Deck and Planechase Anthologies — It’s notable that WOTC is beginning to rerelease a selection of older supplemental decks as “_____ Anthology” every year, as noted by the Commander Anthology that’s being released this summer.

    A couple glaring omissions from the “notable cards” — Ancestral Vision from the DD:Jace vs. Chandra set, and The Rack from Duels of the Planeswalkers. Vision is the most expensive card in the set by far, and that version of The Rack is the only one printed in the new card frame with new art. It’s the most expensive printing, more expensive than the original Antiquities, with the only foil printing (Time Spiral) being pricier.

Join the conversation

Want Prices?

Browse thousands of prices with the first and most comprehensive MTG Finance tool around.


Trader Tools lists both buylist and retail prices for every MTG card, going back a decade.