Insider: Organizing Almost Every Unique Card in Magic

Are you a Quiet Speculation member?

If not, now is a perfect time to join up! Our powerful tools, breaking-news analysis, and exclusive Discord channel will make sure you stay up to date and ahead of the curve.

My article today is inspired by our editor Danny who, after reading my articles, asked me how I keep such a large collection organized.

I own roughly 100k cards, down from about 200k half a year ago when I made a big trade, but still a huge amount for most. Of those 100k there are about 61k cards in my collection and the rest is a whole bunch of basic lands, trade stock, bulk, decks and other extra's. More than most online stores I know in The Netherlands and a better selection too. I can find any card in my main collection in under 20 seconds, a little more if it's in a deck or in one of a few special boxes.

(My apologies for some of the crappier pictures: I have to work with whatever I have from that time when a picture can't be retaken).


Early days

My collection once fit into a tiny box, but that of course didn't last long. Some pictures of boxes I used along the way:

Ultra Pro Box



Ten years ago this was my collection (notice all of the above-pictured boxes still being present at this stage):

2007 collection

As you can see, there are many different boxes, several binders and the drawers from the cabinet on the right. The collection remained this way for a long time, but eventually I reached the stage where this became unmanageable. This is when I decided that I needed to overhaul my process. At this time, I was sorting cards by rarity, color and alphabet. For lower volumes, this works quite decently and you can quickly find cards. Unfortunately, when you are mostly adding cards when a new set is released, and you then need to go through all your red commons to sort in the red cards from the new set each and every time, it gets very tedious.

Recent times

As you might have guessed, I decided I needed another level of sorting: by set. Paradoxically, because cards naturally come sorted by set when you get them from a box, it was easy to add this sorting level. Of course, this did require that I re-sort what by then amounted to about twenty to thirty thousand commons. A month or two of sporadically sorting cards later, I had a stack of commons divided by set. I added them back into my cabinet, and it became easier to add new sets.

I always knew that I wanted to do the uncommons and rares too, but as those were in smaller numbers it was less of a priority. Of course, after a few years, the uncommons started to become challenging too, so I did the same for them and finally the rares as well. This all happened before mythics came around, and I have always sorted them with the rares in any case.


Life was good until I had the opportunity to pick up a large collection. I estimate at least 100k cards, fortunately largely sorted by set. I got a great deal, but now I somehow had to figure out what I wanted to do with these. I decided at this point that going for a full playset of Magic would make for a good challenge, but that I would need to figure out how to merge with this new collection and then figure out exactly what I have. I always want to keep the best looking copies per card too. A daunting task.

A picture of the collection I bought:


That's 42 binders for sets and all boxes in the picture are filled with bulk.


The bulk of this collection was also roughly sorted by set (and often even by color and alphabet), so what I would do was go through the bulk, get out everything from the set's binder and merge with the bulk. After that, I would take out the best looking cards for a playset and sort the rest of the cards by rarity and value. I would then stack them on my (big) table with the sets sorted in chronological order. When I was done with this I took the sorted cards from my own collection, added those best looking cards from the other collection, filtered out the best looking copies per card and penny sleeved them. Finally I sorted the results by rarity and added the cards to a 800-card box per set. When I was done it looked like this:

After sorting

During my sorting and filtering, I also updated a spreadsheet with the cards I own. I spent almost three weeks of vacation time on this and creating my spreadsheet...

From here, these boxes moved into a filing cabinet, as shown here:

Some sets don't fit in a single box. Other is anything not from the first printing with normal corners.
Other is anything not from the first printing with normal corners.

Current situation

If I have a single card come in for a set, it gets tedious to pull out a box and add it. I often have large volumes come in at once, but split across many sets, so that gets very tedious. What I do is keep a 5000-count box with dividers for every set, available for storage of incoming cards. Whenever the box overflows I take the largest few sets and sort those into their boxes. This ensures that whenever I am adding cards to the main collection I add a decent number per box while only pulling out a few boxes. I'll also sort away any set that is complete; however, so far I have no complete playsets of any normal set (I do have them for sets like the more recent Commander and Conspiracy releases that I simply traded for as playsets). I'm closest for Antiquities; help would be appreciated.

5000-count box
Staging area.

Lessons Learned

The way I store my collection keeps changing. I am pretty happy with my current setup. However, there's a chance that I will come up with something better in the future. Right now, there's a lot of wasted space in the set boxes for smaller sets like, for example, Starter '99. Perhaps ultimately someone comes up with an automated storage solution that sorts away and retrieves cards for you. Basically, my main lesson is that there's always room for improvement and that until an automated solution is devised, it will always remain tedious work.

I'm curious to hear how you manage your collection or stock and whether you do anything different from what I do. Leave a comment with your system below.

Avatar photo

Niels Rietkerk

Niels currently lives in Amsterdam, The Netherlands and has been collecting, playing and trading since '97. A casual player at heart, his first official tournament was the Unhinged prerelease. You can most commonly find him playing multiplayer Commander, probably trying to talk his way to a win. He has always been passionate about trading, but these days leaves the more volatile markets to people with more time, instead focusing primarily on bulk and collections. As he's one of the most prolific forum members it should come as no surprise that Niels loves to discuss. Feel free to comment or reach out to him on the forums or through Twitter.

View More By Niels Rietkerk

Posted in Collecting, Finance, Free Insider, ION Academy, Timeless Info

Have you joined the Quiet Speculation Discord?

If you haven't, you're leaving value on the table! Join our community of experts, enthusiasts, entertainers, and educators and enjoy exclusive podcasts, questions asked and answered, trades, sales, and everything else Discord has to offer.

Want to create content with Quiet Speculation?

All you need to succeed is a passion for Magic: The Gathering, and the ability to write coherently. Share your knowledge of MTG and how you leverage it to win games, get value from your cards – or even turn a profit.

4 thoughts on “Insider: Organizing Almost Every Unique Card in Magic

  1. Thank you for this article, seriously thank you! This subject needs to be talked about in more depth! I think this article will help get the topic of organization on more people’s minds and will hopefully lead to more talk about organization and inventorying of collections.

    1. You’re welcome!

      You said this needs to be talked about in more depth, did you miss anything?

      Unfortunately I don’t have my own store so I can only write about how I organize my collection. I have seen the setup of several stores, but I don’t know how they got to their systems. I also know of some stores that aren’t happy with the systems they have in place.

      I would probably have suggestions for stores on how to most efficiently add cards to the inventory. Ultimately it comes down to having some assembly line like setup though. Mostly I work hard at being lazy, which leads me to think about optimizing my setup.

      1. Different methods of sorting, consideration for sizes/value/consistency.

        So I have the same thing as you going on, where I have a collection that is about 70-90k and then my sell/trade stuff that is about 250-300k. I organize my collection sorting by color than alphabetical. I use this system as I wanted a system where I didn’t have to remember the set it came in or have to go through multiple boxes to get a playset. For my sell/trade stuff I sort it by rarity, then set, then alphabetically. I have the Rares/Mythic Rares in 3 5k boxes. Uncommons: I have the sets in alphabetical order and put into multiple 5k boxes. Commons: Each Set or Block (if I dont have over 3k) has it’s own 5k box. These sorted alphabetically. Foils: Are sorted by alphabetical set, and then alphabetically. Promos: Same as Foils.

        I am all about efficiency but feel like I am missing out when it comes to my sell/trade cards. It is hard to conform to buy lists as each store want to receive cards in their own special way.

        1. I always want the first printing of a card (with normal corners), so I would never have to look for copies from other sets. Mostly it sounds to me like adding a couple hundred cards to you collection would be very tedious as you would have to go through all of it. Do you at least have dividers per starting letter?

          Does your sell/trade stuff need to be easily accessible for someone to look through? If not I would only make sure everything of a set is together, as it seems likely to me that someone buying would want it sorted by set.

          I’m in the rather advantageous position that I usually deal with a single store whom I have a lot of history with. I know how they want cards sorted (set/alphabet), so I do that and they trust me enough to just accept whatever I send them without discussing upfront what exactly is in there: I just tell them that I want $X, they have a look at what comes in and agree (I even get the impression that usually they don’t even look). I put EX cards upside down and worse cards flipped front to back, so the condition is coded in while keeping the sorting. As I tend to keep things sorted similarly this is pretty easy for me to provide.

          I can’t be sure what other stores usually ask for, but I would expect that having everything for a set stored together is very common. I would certainly consider going for that.

Join the conversation

Want Prices?

Browse thousands of prices with the first and most comprehensive MTG Finance tool around.

Trader Tools lists both buylist and retail prices for every MTG card, going back a decade.