[MTGO] 1 Year, 100 Tix May Report

Modern, Modern and Modern again. Thanks to Modern, and after only five months, I have doubled the value of my account!

Similarly to January, my Modern specs played a big role in boosting my bankroll in May. So no surprise today, I’ll discuss Modern specs. Modern positions are the bread and butter of speculators on MTGO and a big chunk of your bankroll should be dedicated to such positions.

The unlocked article from the Nine Months of Portfolio Management Series this month is Part 6–Standard Rotation Opportunities. Standard rotation and the subsequent price decreases start quite early on MTGO, as early as May.

Unlike paper Magic this trend is merciless with digital cards. Standard staples that once were over 15 Tix can plunge as low as 0.3 Tix. But it’s also a great opportunity to invest into several positions with an almost guaranteed positive outcome.

Before we begin May’s report, be sure to check out the following links (if you haven’t already):

Doubling Up: +46.4% in May, +139% Since January

In January, my Modern picks jump-started the project with an explosive +54% increase. After a subdued month of April almost everything went up in May, especially my Modern positions.

Old positions, new positions, all have increased by about 50% within few weeks and greatly benefited the account. Here is the graph of the progression.

Summary of May’s Specs

Anticipating or reacting to the Modern Masters 2015 reprint list, all my new acquisitions with the exception of Soul of Shandalar in May were in Modern. There’s nothing extraordinary here as pretty much any non-reprinted and playable Modern cards went up this past month.

But there is nothing more efficient. Speculations on MTGO, and especially with Modern positions, is very often a game of buying known good cards when everybody else is looking elsewhere (looking at Dragons of Tarkir for instance), and selling when everybody wants them.

I was also pleased to see my Pauper positions recovering from their dip at the end of April. I sold Mental Note during nice price recovery that is actually still going on–I didn’t want to miss this opportunity this time around. While Flame Slash hasn’t moved from its floor yet, I’m still holding on Innocent Blood and Moment’s Peace as they have more potential in my opinion.

Lastly, I also performed two other short sells in May. In addition to short-selling Jeskai Ascendancy between April 28th and May 1st with a net +2.65 Tix profit I also short-sold Narset, Enlightened Master and Surrak Dragonclaw. This time around profits were not as great with +0.42 Tix for Narset and -0.09 Tix for Surrak.

There’s a lot to say about short-selling on MTGO and with Magic cards in general. Although the concept is nothing new for the finance world this is a speculating move that has long been considered an impossible fantasy with Magic finance. The process is simple: I borrowed the cards, sold them and bought them back cashing in the difference.

To be totally transparent, I borrowed the card from my main account, and to be totally fair I also applied fees to these transactions (2% of the value of the cards when borrowed and per week until given back). These fees would apply to anyone willing to borrow cards from my main account, so anyone can replicate the specs done with my “100 Tix 1 year” account.

I’m currently working on a detailed article about short-selling on MTGO. This article is likely to be two- or three-part series for QS Insiders, so be on the lookout for it.

A Modern World

Modern is by far the best place to speculate on MTGO. With literally hundreds of different speculative targets to chose from and high price variations Modern can generate a consistent stream of Tix for small and big bankrolls.

The strength of Modern positions is that they are cyclical. When the interest for Modern is limited (during Standard PTs, new set releases, etc…) prices are low. And when Modern again becomes the center of players’ attention (Modern PTs, Modern MOCS or PTQ season) prices sharply rise. Even in between these identifiable seasons a lot of cards simply fluctuate up and down in a very predictable way.

Unlike the Standard metagame, the Modern metagame is very stable and any card that has been good and pricey will be good and pricey again. Only bans have a definitive negative impact on the prices of Modern cards.

In March and April, and after the little boost produced by the Modern Pro Tour Fate Reforged, prices all across the Modern format started to tank. The attention and Tix from players were shifting to Standard again with the release of Dragons of Tarkir. In addition, the fear of reprints in Modern Masters 2015 (whose list was unknown at the time) pushed for further price drops–a perfect buying opportunity for Modern specs.

When the list of MM2015 was spoiled, non-reprinted cards soared, many increasing by 50% or more in a week or so. On the day the list was spoiled, Matt Lewis and I put together two special MTGO Market Reports discussing Mythics, and Rare, Uncommons and Commons that constituted several of the best speculative targets at that moment.

When big announcements like the MM2015 list are made it doesn’t take long before prices start moving. These two reports certainly helped QS insiders with their MTGO Modern speculations.

Between May 8th (when we made our buying recommendations) and Wednesday June 3rd, the 32 recommendations we made were up by an average of 67.4%. We have already recommended selling six of these positions, Slippery BoglePyromancer AscensionGitaxian ProbeFauna ShamanPath to Exile and Serum Visions, which were up by an average of 149%.

Next Month

Next month I will be half way through this project. With an additional push from my Modern positions the account should be over 250 Tix by then. We will also reveal the person who guessed the closest for the six first months contest.


Thank you for reading and following!

Sylvain Lehoux

Post categories: 100T1Y, Finance, Free, Free Finance, MTGO

Are you a Quiet Speculation member yet?

If not, now is a perfect time to join up! Our powerful tools, breaking-news analysis, and exclusive Discord channel will make sure you stay up to date and ahead of the curve.

Have you joined the Quiet Speculation Discord yet?

If you haven't, you're leaving value on the table! Join our community of experts, enthusiasts, entertainers, and educators and enjoy exclusive podcasts, questions asked and answered, trades, sales, and everything else Discord has to offer.

Want to write for Quiet Speculation?

All you need to succeed is a passion for Magic: The Gathering, an aptitude for getting value from your cards, and the ability to write coherently. Share your knowledge of MTG and how you leverage it to play the game for less – or even turn a profit.
Sylvain Lehoux

Sylvain Lehoux

Sylvain started playing Mtg in 1998 and played at competitive level for more than 10 years including several GP and 3 PT. When he moved to Atlanta in 2010 for his job he sold all his cards and stopped "playing". In 2011 he turned to Mtg Online and he experimented whether it was possible to successfully speculate on this platform. Two years later and with the help of the QS community his experience has grown tremendously and investing on MTGO has proven to be greatly successful. He is now sharing the knowledge he acquired during his MTGO journey! @Lepongemagique on Twitter

More Posts

Enjoy what you just read? Share it with the world!
Share on Reddit
Tweet about this on Twitter
Share on Facebook

7 thoughts on “[MTGO] 1 Year, 100 Tix May Report

  1. Great work. There’s something to be said for being on a short bankroll and seriously diversifying, you never have to reach too far to spot a good spec and you never get too deep into a spec that may turn out to be bad.

    1. Thanks. You are absolutely right. That’s a big difference from my main account. Here, 10 copies of Mental Note or Deceiver Exarch make an enormous difference on my bankroll. And I’m almost guaranty to get the best buying or selling prices with only 2 or 3 playsets to deal with.

      It’s nice to see that any % increase makes a difference.

  2. Awesome stuff, I’d be fascinated to read more about the cyclical fluctuations in between Modern seasons, since they’re somewhat less intuitive than the normal long-term Standard vs Modern demand fluctuations.

    Side note: Parts 5 and 6 of Portfolio Management are not actually unlocked currently.

    1. Thanks!

      Some cards don’t fluctuate and some are simply a roller coaster, up and down constantly. Serra Ascendant is a good example, since Jan 2013 the cycles are very constant.

      The parts 5 and 6 should have been unlocked by now.

    1. No mythic from KTK has yet emerged as a big winner. Wingmate, Sorin, Anafenza, Sarkhan and even Sidissi could double/triple in price with BFZ. All may increase until October. After this date it all depends on PT BFZ.

      I also really like all of the FRF mythics to the exception of Ghastly C and Temp T. Buying a basket of all of the 13 other mythic could pay off. All have the potential to be played in serious Standard decks. The winner(s) could easily be valued around 15 Tix. Not a big increase of it’s Monastery Mentor but a home run if Torrent Elemental.

      DTK also have a lot of nice mythics and rares. Although the choice may me trickier since it’s a 3rd set, higher prices, etc… some of these cards are going to gain a lot of value. Even a 20 Tix raptor could be a 40 Tix raptor next fall is the metagame favors it.

      Spread your Tix in as many different positions as possible is always a better bet than buying only few different cards.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Want Prices?

Browse thousands of prices with the first and most comprehensive MTG Finance tool around.

Trader Tools lists both buylist and retail prices for every MTG card, going back a decade.