Insider: Speccing Around The Locust God

Are you a Quiet Speculation member?

If not, now is a perfect time to join up! Our powerful tools, breaking-news analysis, and exclusive Discord channel will make sure you stay up to date and ahead of the curve.

Welcome back, readers!

Last weekend I managed to play in one prerelease event for Hour of Devastation. I went BWg thanks to Pride Sovereign, Ramunap Hydra, and Grind // Dust (though in all fairness the card that won most games was my promo God-Pharaoh's Gift). But the card in my pool that caught my eye was one I didn't even play: The Locust God.

I started thinking about how I don't have any blue-red Commander decks and realized that The Locust God could be a lot of fun. What I really like about him is that he provides a win condition based on something you want to do already, which is draw a lot of cards. The Locust God is one of the few Commanders who can do this (the other obvious one being Niv-Mizzet, the Firemind).

We've already seen several legendary creatures from a new set create spikes in older cards, especially when the new creature is unique. We saw it with Omnath, Locus of Rage, The Gitrog Monster, and most recently Hapatra, Vizier of Poisons. I think The Locust God will likely follow suit.

In fact, a card with many of the same synergies was the catalyst of some Commander spikes a few years back: Nekusar, the Mindrazer. The Locust God pairs with a slightly different set of cards (it triggers off of your draws, whereas Nekusar triggered off of the opponent's)—but clearly there's a precedent for interest in this type of card in the Commander community.

A lot of players are excited about The Scarab God because it plays well with a blue-black Zombies deck and its second ability can be very powerful against the right decks. However, we already have a lot of great blue-black Zombie generals, so most auto-includes in those types of decks are already valuable. That second ability can also be underwhelming against creature-light decks (like Mizzix of the Izmagnus).

But back to The Locust God. Reviewing EDHREC, there are some very strong auto-includes for the deck. The signature cards (as of 7/14) are:

  1. Skullclamp
  2. Purphoros, God of the Forge
  3. Bident of Thassa
  4. Ashnod's Altar
  5. Arjun, the Shifting Flame
  6. Impact Tremors
  7. Coastal Piracy
  8. Whirlpool Warrior
  9. Windfall
  10. Mindmoil
  11. Alhammarret's Archive
  12. Teferi's Puzzle Box
  13. Jace's Archivist
  14. Winds of Change

Some other cards, while not considered "signature card" yet in the archetype, have a good chance of becoming auto-includes if it takes off. In my opinion, that includes the following:

  1. Wheel of Fortune
  2. Blue Sun's Zenith (top card, but not a signature card)
  3. Reforge the Soul (top card, but not a signature card)
  4. Time Reversal (top card, but not a signature card)
  5. Pull from Tomorrow
  6. Kozilek, Butcher of Truth
  7. Molten Psyche
  8. Stroke of Genius
  9. Time Spiral

Combined that's a pretty sizeable list of cards. However, many of these are already very expensive, so the potential for massive gains on them is pretty limited (if a card is $40 and gains $5 then your gain is only 12.5%, etc.). Luckily, that's not the case for all of them.

As I've mentioned in previous articles, when I spec on Commander cards I tend to put an emphasis on 1) How long ago was the last printing? 2) Does it have any reprints? and 3) What rarity was it printed at?

There was an error retrieving a chart for Time Reversal

Time Reversal is my top pick for spec targets for The Locust God; it has two printings, both of which were at mythic in core sets (which tend to sell worse than block sets). It was last printed in M12.

Regular copies can be had for under $1, nearly bulk status for mythics. More importantly, foils are sitting in the $5-ish range (and they are absolutely stunning). I looked to pick up some extra copies and found most websites were sold out and there were only three on TCG Player (for both printings combined). I bought 13 copies from Cardkingdom while writing this article.

There was an error retrieving a chart for Arjun, the Shifting Flame

While there aren't any foil versions of Arjun, the Shifting Flame, it has a single printing in the Mizzix Commander deck back in 2015. The ability is extremely powerful, especially when your win condition is based off of card drawing, so the fact that you lose what was left in your hand isn't as detrimental (though it can lead to awkward or difficult decisions).

This card is currently sitting around $1 as well, so the investment cost is low. It is important to note that WoTC did state that the new Iconic Masters set will include Sphinxs (and this card is a Sphinx) so there is some reprint risk.

There was an error retrieving a chart for Mindmoil

As I missed the original Ravnica block when it came out (I was on an MTG hiatus during college) I didn't even know this one existed. It's currently a bulk rare, so the buy-in is extremely low. Unlike Arjun above, it has the benefit of being an enchantment, which tends to be harder to get rid of than creatures.

Interestingly enough, while the regular version is a bulk rare, foils have recently spiked. They now have a 10x multiplier and are sitting in the $5-ish range, with just four copies on TCGPlayer. This indicates that demand for the card is on the rise; regular copies could easily be soon to follow suit.

There was an error retrieving a chart for Molten Psyche

Here we have another bulk rare that could show some very solid gains. it currently only has a single printing from Scars of Mirrodin (which came out almost seven years ago). Foils are currently sitting in the $2 range.

This one is interesting because it can also serve as a win condition (given the propensity of wheel effects in this archetype). I did find that getting the necessary number of artifacts to turn on metalcraft was a bit more difficult than I expected (my version plays mostly instants and sorceries), though I plan on making tweaks to my version in the upcoming week.

There was an error retrieving a chart for Whirlpool Warrior

Yet another bulk rare (they can be purchased for under $0.5 each). This card has three printings, but two of those are Planechase and Planechase Anthology (neither of which were particularly large print runs). The original print run was all the way back in Apocalypse, which released in 2001 (16 years ago).

Foils have about a 10x multiplier (and are sitting in the $5 range), which shows that there is definitely strong demand for the foil versions. However, if The Locust God takes off and this remains a "signature card" showing up in over 50% of the decklists published online, the foil could easily double or triple up from its current price.

I actually like the idea of the regular version as a nice "penny stock" given it could easily double or triple up. Unloading large quantities of penny-stock picks is often difficult, but picking up a few at their current value to trade later isn't a bad decision.

There was an error retrieving a chart for Jace's Archivist

So I know I'm beating the same drum here, but I'm a big fan of bulk-rare picks because the investment cost for a decent size position is low, and there's a lot of upside and a relatively low floor (especially if you're trading other bulk rares for them).

This card has three printings. Two of them are Commander printings (in 2013 and 2015) and there is only one foil printing (Magic 2012) which was five years ago and again in a core set. Foils are sitting around $3 or so, so the multiplier is in the 4-5x range; but it's popular in other decks as well (like Nekusar, the Mindrazer and Mizzix of the Izmagnus).

There was an error retrieving a chart for Stroke of Genius

Stroke of Genius used to sit in the $5 range and has slowly slid down to the sub-$2 range (thanks to reprints in Commander 2014 and 2015), but my pick here is actually the judge foil version. It's the only foil option and retains the original artwork, which is somewhat iconic thanks to the Tolarian Academy decks of old.

This is actually one of the original judge foils from back in 1998, in the same series as Gaea's Cradle and Lightning Bolt. So the argument is that the number of judges back in 1998 who received this card is likely a lot fewer than the number of judges who receive promos nowadays.

I honestly didn't realize this card was a judge foil (as I hadn't seen anyone play it), but it's definitely a great Commander card. It can act as both a source of major card advantage or a kill card (with enough mana), and has obvious synergy with The Locust God.


There we have some of my favorite picks for The Locust God Commander speculation targets. There are likely a lot more (as Magic has a very long history of card-draw spells), but these are the ones that came most readily to mind for me. Got any other good picks? Let me know in the comments below.

4 thoughts on “Insider: Speccing Around The Locust God

  1. David,

    This article was very helpful to me! I have heard some rumblings about the Locust God and I know he’s already responsible for the movement in Winds of Change. Your article contains great suggestions for what else may spike on his popularity. I made a few small purchases based on your recommendations. I was shocked to see how few foil Time Reversals were out there (besides Dan Bock’s overpriced copies on eBay).

    What do you think of Wheel of Fortune as a RL pickup for this deck?



    1. Obviously Wheel of Fortune is fantastic in this deck. My only issue is that it’s already very expensive. It will no doubt move, but I usually base my specs on % gains as opposed to $ gains. If this deck takes off I could see Wheel moving up another $10-$15, but due to the fact that it’s already sitting at $50…your gains would be likely be in the 20-25% range. If you wanted to sell then you’d likely have to do so at TCG low-10% (standard quicksell rate on Facebook) or buylist..both of which would likely wipe out any gains you may have made.

  2. Mindmoil foils look to be all but gone, I sold 4 copies at $7 and then again at $11, and the price point looks to be higher now.

    You missed foils of these:

    -Whirlpool Rider and Whirlpool Drake. Rider also shows up in Legacy Dredge decks from time to time, usually of the manaless variety.

    -Credit Voucher. One-time use, but red has plenty of ways to recur artifacts. Plus, the card name reads like it should be in an Un-set.

    -Tolarian Winds, assuming you can still find cheap copies.

    -Distant Melody (probably just the Lorwyn version).

    and both foils (if applicable, and price depending) and non-foils of these:

    -Memory Jar. RL and best draw-7 in the game, IMO.

    -Consecrated Sphinx (could show up in Iconic Masters though).

    -Psychic Possession. I mostly only like foils, but could be a decent bulk rare play.

    -Opposition. If every G/W/(x) token deck wants Glare of Subdual, don’t you want this here? Plus, you can tap down lands if need be. Combo with stuff like Intruder Alarm and Bonded Fetch / Merfolk Looter if you want to get cute and draw your deck / tap down everything.

    -Magus of the Wheel, if you can find copies at the old price (it just spiked).

    1. Definitely a few good picks in there. I like the Distant Melody pick, foils do have a 5x multiplier already, but Morningtide foils are definitely rare. I also like foil Tolarian Winds (at the old seems someone has tried to force the prize up 900%). I also could see Credit Voucher (specifically foils) being a decent spec. The whirlpool Rider/Drake are definitely interesting options as well. I didn’t pick Memory Jar because it’s already around $14+ (I was focused on cheaper spec options). Psychic Possession is definitely interesting option as playing that many Wheel effects is pretty nasty. Opposition could definitely be powerful, but it doesn’t actively win you the just slows your opponents down. Magus of the Wheel was on my radar as well, but I was focused on cheaper ones and as I was writing this it was already pushing $5 (now it’s more like $8-9). Lastly, Consecrated Sphinx…I’ve happily been selling off my extra copies of this card. With Iconic masters coming out in a few months and WoTC stating that Sphinx’s were in it (and it sounded like they were focusing on “Iconic” creatures of the tribes listed) it’s hard to believe that the only sphinx worth more than $5 won’t show up…I’d rather NOT try to risk holding onto that card hoping to see some modest (% wise) gains…Thanks for the other suggestions though.

Join the conversation

Want Prices?

Browse thousands of prices with the first and most comprehensive MTG Finance tool around.

Trader Tools lists both buylist and retail prices for every MTG card, going back a decade.

Quiet Speculation