Insider: Conspiracy Theories

Are you a Quiet Speculation member?

If not, now is a perfect time to join up! Our powerful tools, breaking-news analysis, and exclusive Discord channel will make sure you stay up to date and ahead of the curve.

Welcome back, readers and speculators! While I certainly enjoyed writing about non-financial stuff, this is in fact a MTG finance website so it's only right that I get back to the subject you guys and gals are here for.

Today's article will look at the financial implications of Conspiracy. I choose to write this article after Conspiracy had been tested out by players because multiplayer draft is a very novel concept, which makes it difficult to evaluate financially. When companies test the waters with new products they usually either hit big or miss wildly (guess which did which).


I applaud WoTC for trying something different. I ran a poll in our forums (and talked to local players) regarding their feelings towards Conspiracy as a whole to gauge people's thoughts on the set. We need to gauge demand to determine the likelihood that packs will keep getting cracked and singles will keep entering the market.

We've already seen that the reprinted high-dollar staples (Exploration, Stifle, Misdirection) took a nosedive in value (it was humorous to see how many copies dealers at GP Atlanta had in their case, clearly trying to unload before Conspiracy hit). But we now need to determine if they will likely stay that low or if the excitement of Conspiracy will wear off and after a bunch of reprints hit the market if they begin to dry up as demand for Conspiracy drafts dries up.

And the Results Are in...

According to the poll I ran, about 60% were the new set, and about 40% for it (with 55 votes so the margin of error is probably pretty high--maybe +/-5%).

To be honest I expected it to be a lot more lopsided, based on talking to our local player base. The consensus seems to be that the drafts are fun, but because it's only one game played they are very short and people suffer more from the natural variance inherent in Magic (mana flood and mana screw being pretty common). There are several different deck archetypes , but quite honestly not a ton (R/x defenders, U/W flyers, Mono-green beats are the ones I've seen the most).

What Does This Mean?

A decent number of players do enjoy the draft style and will continue to draft. What this means is that the average value of the rares will continue to drop as more and more get opened. This also means that we aren't at the price floor for almost anything out of the set, so if you start buying in now be prepared to lose some more money.

It is important to note, though, that while a decent percentage of the player base does want to keep drafting it, a larger portion has already grown weary of it. This does imply that while we haven't hit the price floor yet, we will do so sooner rather than later. It is unlikely that the people who want to keep drafting it will keep opening up the desirable rares at the rate the overall player base wants (though the value per pack will likely decline to the point that it is not worth cracking packs just for the chase rares).

We should also keep in mind that the new core set comes out in a little over a month, which is a standard 3x pack draft format, which will likely pull away some of the people who would have Conspiracy drafted. We saw a similar thing happen with Modern Masters (though in a much more compact time frame).

The first couple of weeks after Modern Masters released, as more product kept getting cracked, the price of the rares in the set continued to drop. Supply dried up quickly afterwards and cards started to stabilize. Demand began to increase as WoTC kept pushing the format and the prices began to rise again.

So my list of potential spec targets from Conspiracy are:

  1. >Exploration - This is a casual all-star and it does see some Legacy play in Enchantress and Lands.
  2. Stifle - A Legacy all-star whose popularity waxes and wanes depending on how popular the tempo decks in the format are.
  3. Misdirection - Another Legacy card with a demand curve similar to a roller coaster. It sees play in some Sneak and Show builds as well as the Omnishow builds (pretty much acting as a fifth and/or sixth Force of Will in counter wars).
  4. Pernicious Deed - This is one of the few cards on the list that's both a casual and a Legacy favorite. It sees play in Rock style decks (most often Nic Fit) but also finds a home in almost every GBx EDH deck that can fit it in. It serves as an excellent rattlesnake style card (i.e. one that tempts people to leave you alone), is a mana-efficient sweeper, and doesn't hit your (or anyone's) planeswalkers.
  5. Council's Judgment - This newcomer is proving it can fit into Legacy as a "better" Oblivion Ring, given they don't get the card back ever (unlike O-ring which can be removed) and it doesn't target so it can hit Legacy's problem child True-Name Nemesis (as well as Progenitus). Luckily, for us speculators it tends to be a one- or two-of, so the early on set demand should be more limited, thus allowing the cards price to settle low before starting its eventual climb.
  6. Realm Seekers - This is my pick for casual favorite from the set. It's green (EDH's strongest color), has a decent mana cost for EDH, can be massive against the players who like to draw tons of cards, and most importantly allows us to search for any land. There are so many powerful utility (Yavimaya Hollow) or big mana (Gaea's Cradle) lands that the ability to tutor them up for three green is huge.
  7. Mirari's Wake - This is just one of those cards that never stays in my trade binder for more than two weeks. This one came in at mythic so the price of the original should remain relatively steady (though it has dropped some upon the reprint spoiling). Green-white tends to be the "big mana" color combination in EDH along with pure green, so a card that helps that play style along will always have demand.
  8. Scourge of the Throne - It's a mythic dragon that gives you a free additional attack step, so long as you attack a specific person(s). The fact that it's mono-red also means it can fit into a larger number of potential decks (being mono-colored is always helpful when it comes to EDH specific cards).
  9. Altar of Dementia - This card's only other printing was in Tempest and it's typically one that a lot of people don't know about, but once they see it in action they really want it. This provides a mana-free/instant speed/colorless sac outlet that can serve as a win condition. I play a copy in every EDH deck with a lot of creatures for that exact reason. It's especially good in decks that pump creatures for a turn or two (Ezuri/Márton Stromgald/Kamahl) as you can attack/kill one opponent and then sacrifice everyone to mill out another (Just beware of targeting decks with Eldrazi). It also serves as a way to punish decks that wrath repeatedly. I love it's current super low price as I expect once Conspiracy demand dies down this will easily be back up to $5-6.

Legacy Spotlight

  • A Grixis Painter deck made top 4 of the SCG Invitational. This is a pretty off-the-wall build and it probably had a lot of suprise factor going for it. However, there were a lot of Legacy rounds for the Invitational against a lot of very talented players, so this deck's top 4 spot is not something to dismiss. It's almost a Grixis "hate deck" with a combo finish; you've got Countertop lock and Ensnaring Bridge main with a Magus of the Moon and Meekstone in the board, and you throw in a couple ways to tutor up Painter and Grindstone. I like how he didn't devote the main part of the deck to the combo, but instead included it as a "once we've run each other out of resources I can just auto win". The maindeck Nihil Spellbomb serves as a way to mill through Emrakul's (with the triggers all on the stack you can remove everything with the spellbomb.
  • A U/R Delver deck made top 16 of the SCG Open running four Searing Blood in the board (which is a spectacular hate card against Elves and Death and Taxes).
  • It's nice to see a Death and Taxes deck adopt both Council's Judgement and Armageddon (old school tech) in the board.

8 thoughts on “Insider: Conspiracy Theories

    1. I honestly believe we’re close, but I don’t think we’re there yet. This is NOT a short print run set, WoTC will keep printing it as long as there is demand. Having said that, my poll indicates that the demand will continue to decrease as many players tire of it or when the new core set releases. I expect the price of the cards in conspiracy to continue to drop slowly until the core set release. This will likely be there floor and that’s when I’d advocate picking up what you want to speculate on.

      1. While they will print while there is demand, I don’t think there will be demand once M15 hits. Plus very few people are buying boxes just to bust open unlike normal sets. If I was going to buy cards off of TCG player or something, I would wait a few more weeks to see if it drops a little more. But if I’m trying to acquire through trading or buying them closer to buy list prices, I’d start right now and not miss any opportunities.

        Also I thought I was going to see predictions for what price the cards would end up at.

        1. I would love to have attempted that, but I keep hearing wildly different thoughts on conspiracy, some areas love it, others hate it, and without a good ability to gauge the interest we can’t really gauge how much will be opened which directly affects the price point. I wish more people had answered my poll in the forums (55 is a decent number of course, but I’d have loved to have broken 100) as the more data points, the more comfortable I’d feel guestimating prices. However, I do feel that the logic behind WHEN the price should be lowest is sound, so while you may lose a bit of money between now and then if you buy/trade for the cards in the long run I think all of the ones I listed are good pickups.

    2. Of the nine cards discussed in detail, the only two that look (on mtgstocks) like they might be at a bottom are scourge of the throne and council’s judgment. And neither has been flat long enough to have much confidence that those are really bottoms.The others are still declining, some precipitously. Besides, the ideal buy point isn’t the moment they first touch the bottom, but the moment when they start to go back up from it. Still too early to buy.

        1. Agreed. The set is still too new for the prices to have settled (for the most part), but I suggest they’ll begin to do so within the next 3 weeks.

Join the conversation

Want Prices?

Browse thousands of prices with the first and most comprehensive MTG Finance tool around.

Trader Tools lists both buylist and retail prices for every MTG card, going back a decade.