Lying, Cheating, Stealing and Scum-Baggery – A Practical Guide

Are you a Quiet Speculation member?

If not, now is a perfect time to join up! Our powerful tools, breaking-news analysis, and exclusive Discord channel will make sure you stay up to date and ahead of the curve.

In the (opposite of) the holiday spirit, I'm here to talk to you about all the horrible, evil, and morally reprehensible crap that goes on in Magic these days.  Now, don't get me wrong; I think that the vast, vast majority of Magic players are lovely, good, and honest.  I don't thing we Have A Problem In The Community, on the whole.  I don't think there is some sort of epidemic, or systemic problem.

But I do know there's a lot of garbage that goes on, and in a game with 13+ million people, that's basically inevitable.

We might not be able to put an end to it for good, but we can at least educate ourselves about it.


Counterfeit, Fake and dubious "Proxy" Cards

David Schumann - How To Identify Fake Magic Cards

Dot patterns on fake cards are usually much less intricate. This is one of the easiest things to look for when checking older cards (though to see the dot patterns properly you’ll probably need to pick up a jeweler’s loop). It is important to keep in mind that dot patterns will vary from set to set. It is a good idea to have a common that you know is legitimate from the same set when doing side by side comparisons.

Another printer discrepancy that may indicate a fake is a minor difference or variation in the card or artwork itself. Many fakes will display differences in the artwork or text such as in the picture below (the card name text is clearly off).

Read More

Some fakes now pass bend tests...

Jason Alt - Fake Fetch Lands Spotted In The Wild

Be careful when ordering online. If your card is worth more than about $30, make sure you test the card to make sure it’s genuine. The light test is a very good quick and dirty test to see if a card is genuine. However, not to worry. The fakes are not getting that much better. This card apparently felt much different and the typeface looked off. If you do buy a fake card on TCG Player, contact them and they will investigate. If the seller is knowingly selling fakes, they will be dealt with.

Read More

A bright LED shines through an authentic Magic card, but not through the counterfeit on the left.


Corbin Hosler - More Counterfeits Hit The Market

What I do suggest is educating your friends about these. I saw a Craigslist post earlier about someone selling these as “proxies,” and that’s just not okay. Whether there’s any ill intent on the side of the buyer or the seller doesn’t matter; these shouldn’t be in circulation. There are no laws that I’m aware of that prevent this, but the fact is more of these out there do not help our game. Rather than just berating anyone who may think the concept is cool, I would suggest simply educating them about the fact that while it may seem cool to get “Power” for cheap, in the long run it has the potential to destroy the game, and there’s no point in having cheap “Power” if you aren’t able to play it.

Read More

They might be easy to spot, but not -this- easy.

Cheating and Lying


Patrick Chapin - Cheating At the Magic World Championship

Eighteen years ago, tournament Magic was a different animal. There were many players that believed that cheating at Magic was akin to fouling someone in basketball. If you get called for it, you pay the penalty, but that's just part of the game. Some even glamorized it, believing that it was using your intelligence to beat the house, like a group of students beating the casino at Blackjack by counting cards.

In my estimation, somewhere around a third of early Pro Tour players were cheaters. That is an absurd amount. Imagine playing in a tournament, knowing that you were likely to face multiple people a day that were actively trying to cheat you.

I was cheated against in my very first Pro Tour.

Read More

The Much Maligned Marcio Carvalho

Jason Alt - The Man Who Ate Pumpkins

The video evidence is beginning to add up quickly. Allegations of Humphries using the opportunity to shuffle an opponent’s deck (ironically, to prevent the opponent from stacking their deck) to put non-lands on top, forcing repeated Mulligans have been coming in. There is a pretty decent reddit thread devoted to the topic.

Read More

To see the execution of this cheat, watch the video below.

Danny Brown - [VIDEO] See How The Humphries Cheat Works

The community is abuzz with the latest cheating scandal from last weekend. I’m sure aficionados of shady play will say this method has been around for a while, but it’s the first time I’ve seen it done by someone who knows what they’re doing. And even when word first got out and I knew there was something to watch for, it took a few viewings and some well-timed stills to really catch the cheat in action.

Read More

Derek Madlem - [Insider] How To Cheat At Magic Finance

Robbing others of their wealth doesn’t occur solely at the play tables these days. We’ve got scammers on eBay. We’ve got counterfeit rings undermining the financial integrity of the secondary market. We’ve got people committing actual heists, stealing tens of thousands of dollars in Magic cards in mere minutes. And there’s some Faithless Looting occurring at the trade tables every weekend.

Read More

Vultures will always circle fresh meat hoping to get a piece.

Jason Alt-  The Year Of The Cheat

According to the Chinese Zodiac, this is the year of the horse. People born in the year of the Horse are great at communicating and enjoy the spotlight. Horses should avoid marrying rats and rabbits because they would kill their spouse attempting to consummate the union. Even though 2014 isn’t officially the year of the rat, it’s starting to feel like it. Alex Bertoncini.  Trevor Humphries.  Jared Boettcher.  A lot of high profile players were found out to be cheats and frauds this year and there is still nearly an entire month left for us to ferret out a few more cheats. The hits kept coming this week as we had a high-profile disqualification at the Player Championship. Wizards released a statement that mentions that Marcio Carvalho received a disqualification for presenting an illegal deck but it doesn’t really delve too much into what happened. I had to go to social media to find out a bit more.

Read More

I'll take "Number of Explores" for $10,000, Alex.  Double Jeopardy, indeed.

Jason Alt - Just Desserts: Trevor Charles banned 4 years for cheating

Within 24 hours of each other, two investigations into allegations of cheating concluded very abruptly and before anyone knew it, justice was done and two pretty savage cheaters had bitten the dust. We found out about one of them before the DCI made an official announcement due to a pretty epic meltdown on Facebook, posted, edited, deleted but ultimately screencapped and posted to Facebook by Frank Lepore and others.

Read More

Epic meltdown indeed.


Despite this depressing roster of scumbags and wrongdoings, Magic is still as strong as ever. As more events are played under the scrutiny of feature matches and broadcast globally, archived forever, and watched and re-watched, more cheaters will be caught. More cheats will become common knowledge. Maybe one day we'll see lifetime bans for cheating at Magic. Personally, I see no reason for a "convicted" cheater to ever be permitted back in the game, but I'm sure Hasbro doesn't want the DCI just hell-banning people for life. Even if it might be good for the game.

Happy holidays, everyone. Be nice to each other.

Kelly Reid

Founder & Product Manager

View More By Kelly Reid

Posted in Cheating, Counterfeits, Feature, Free, ION Academy, Timeless Info

Have you joined the Quiet Speculation Discord?

If you haven't, you're leaving value on the table! Join our community of experts, enthusiasts, entertainers, and educators and enjoy exclusive podcasts, questions asked and answered, trades, sales, and everything else Discord has to offer.

Want to create content with Quiet Speculation?

All you need to succeed is a passion for Magic: The Gathering, and the ability to write coherently. Share your knowledge of MTG and how you leverage it to win games, get value from your cards – or even turn a profit.

One thought on “Lying, Cheating, Stealing and Scum-Baggery – A Practical Guide

  1. “Despite this depressing roster of scumbags and wrongdoings, Magic is still as strong as ever.”

    I think the dishonesty is in fact a result of the success of Magic. Maybe we should be flattered. There is a huge amount on the line in tournaments and #mtgfinance, more than ever before and growing, and it incentivizes lying cheating and stealing.

    I think there’s a reason that all of the parties found cheating or counterfeiting this year were people with little to no previous ties to the community. Without any social or cultural investment they viewed it as a free opportunity to take their shot and steal from a group that means nothing to them. It’s all of our jobs to vigilantly protect ourselves and ruthlessly root out the grifters. It something doesn’t seem right, it’s probably not.

Join the conversation

Want Prices?

Browse thousands of prices with the first and most comprehensive MTG Finance tool around.

Trader Tools lists both buylist and retail prices for every MTG card, going back a decade.