menu

Insider: MTGO Market Report for June 17th, 2015

Are you a Quiet Speculation member?

If not, now is a perfect time to join up! Our powerful tools, breaking-news analysis, and exclusive Discord channel will make sure you stay up to date and ahead of the curve.

Welcome to the MTGO Market Report as compiled by Sylvain Lehoux and Matthew Lewis. The report is loosely broken down into two perspectives. A broader perspective will be written by Matthew and will focus on recent trends in set prices, taking into account how paper prices and MTGO prices interact. Sylvain will take a closer look at particular opportunities based on various factors such as (but not limited to) set releases, flashback drafts and banned/restricted announcements.

There will be some overlap between the two sections. As always, speculators should take into account their own budget, risk tolerance and current portfolio before taking on any recommended positions.

Redemption

Below are the total set prices for all redeemable sets on MTGO. All prices are current as of June 15th, 2015. The TCG Low and TCG Mid prices are the sum of each set’s individual card prices on TCG Player, either the low price or the mid-price respectively.

All MTGO set prices this week are taken from Goatbot’s website, and all weekly changes are now calculated relative to Goatbot’s ‘Full Set’ prices from the previous week. All monthly changes are also relative to the previous month prices, taken from Goatbot’s website at that time. Occasionally ‘Full Set’ prices are not available, and so estimated set prices are used instead.

Jun17

Return to Ravnica Block & M14

Prices on RTR and GTC continue to tick higher in both paper and MTGO. For paper, there is no expected break in this trend as interest in Modern continues to grow while Standard is in a fallow period. Modern season will get under way in the paper PTQ system in the latter half of the summer, which will sustain interest and rising prices up to the start of the season. MTGO is a little different as the PTQ system will continue to offer a variety of formats to play.

Keep in mind though that the main factor when considering prices of these sets is that Magic Origins (ORI) will be released at the end of July. Like every major set release on MTGO, this will trigger a liquidity crunch in the digital economy, driving up the value of tix relative to cards. Selling cards in a liquidity crunch is a losing proposition, so be sure to sell off your positions in cards from these sets over the next month. Also, core set releases tend to be excellent speculative opportunities so building a supply of tix now, with an eye to deploying in August, is the best course of action.

Value continues to migrate between cards from M14 but the total set price has been flat in the past week and month. With no evidence of rising demand for cards from this set, the increase in the set price since the fall has largely been seen. Although there is little downside to holding cards from this set at current prices, there is little upside evident. Speculators should consider the opportunity cost of continuing to hold cards from this set as the release of ORI approaches.

The lone card to pay attention to in DGM is Voice of Resurgence and it continues to drift down in price. Watch for this card to sink to 20 tix or below, at which point it will be worth considering again. Prices on Modern-playable cards tend to fluctuate up and down over time and keeping tabs on the downswing for cards like this one is good preparation for establishing a position.

Theros Block & M15

These sets were largely stable in price this past week on MTGO as the interest in MM2 drafting steadily winds down. Paper prices are another story as discounting on these sets continues as rotation draws nearer. Right now, speculators should be eyeing junk mythic rares that have bottomed in price, as well as Legacy- or Modern-playable rares and mythic rares that aren't heavily played in Standard.

Exhibit A is Keranos, God of Storms which has risen 50% in the past two weeks, riding the surge of interest in Modern. The fact that JOU is a third set, and that its prime drafting period overlapped with the release of VMA, means this set is in short supply on MTGO and contributes to large price swings. The past price bottom of 10 tix should be considered a good, long-term entry point on this card if prices come down over the summer. Other Modern- or Legacy-playable cards from JOU to keep an eye on for an early bottom are Eidolon of the Great Revel and Mana Confluence.

On the other hand, Thoughtseize of THS is a staple of both Modern and Standard, so it is not up for consideration at the moment for speculators. Standard players will continue to need and use this card, keeping the price elevated. Although the rotation dip on this card will be smaller than most, lower prices are anticipated in October.

Tarkir Block

Similar to THS block, the set prices for KTK, FRF and DTK rebounded this week due to waning interest in MM2 drafting and the resultant normalization of the MTGO economy. Noticeably, KTK in paper was positive for both low and mid TCG prices. Although too early to be certain, it's possible that KTK has bottomed in paper, which would set the stage for further price increases for the MTGO version via redemption.

On a more card-specific front, last week's episode of Brainstorm Brewery featured Gerry T speaking highly of Monastery Mentor from FRF and its utility in Legacy. One doesn't have to look very far to see that this card also shows up strongly in Vintage.

Having a presence in these two formats bodes well for the long-term price of this card, in both paper and on MTGO. Combine that with the upcoming switchover to ORI drafting, as well as FRF and DTK coming off of their price bottoms this week, and this looks like an excellent long-term pickup at its current price. With a Legacy MOCS scheduled for November, and a brand new Standard format coming with the release of Battle for Zendikar, this card has close to zero downside and should be considered an excellent speculative bet.

Modern

GP Charlotte featuring Modern Constructed was held this past weekend. Michael Malone’s Elves took the trophy home and the overall results show how diverse the format is. Tier 2 decks posted strong finishes and the Top 8 decklists themselves could be considered a surprise. Ad Nauseam, Elves, and a Disciple of Griselbrand-Goryo's Vengeance deck featured in the Top 8, along with more familiar faces like U/R Twin, Burn, Affinity and Abzan Collected Company. The Top 62 finishers even included a mill deck!

Splinter Twin variants were the most represented decks in Day 2 and in the Top 8. Infect, Amulet and Jund (or GBx midrange) decks were quieter than expected despite a decent number of players choosing these decks (and two 9-0 Jund lists after Day 1). Scapeshift decks are still nowhere to be seen and Blood Moon was in all decks able to cast it.

This event further pushed prices and revitalized cards not yet on everyone’s radar, including Through the Breach, Goryo's Vengeance, Chord of Calling, Ad Nauseam and Phyrexian Unlife, as well as making a new star of Nourishing Shoal.

Aside from the Lantern Mill deck, none of the decks mentioned above are completely new to this format. Prices have jumped in reaction to these results but speculators should not forget that high prices triggered by spikes are unlikely to sustain themselves, even in the short term. Selling cards that have benefited from this past weekend’s GP result is advisable.

Modern Master 2015 drafts have been extended to July 8th from the initial end date of June 17th. This announcement will delay the expected price rebound and will accentuate the price drop for uncommons (mostly Goremand and Dismember) and some of the cheaper, less-in-demand rares. The whole MM2 set price has been relatively flat for about two weeks now, but delaying further MM2 purchases until the end of this week is recommended in order to get better buying prices.

Finally, Modern Festival preliminaries start next week, June 24th. This one-week event should be the near-term peak for Modern demand. For speculators, this will be a good time to sell Modern positions that have been growing for several weeks now.

Legacy & Vintage

Again this week, nothing has changed with these two formats. Tempest Remastered is the only place to see some price action. Propelled by its top five most expensive cards, the set has established a slow upward trend for its overall price. Wasteland is currently over 70 Tix and it looks like the desired effect to decrease the price of a playset of Wasteland is slowly failing as the price converges to its pre-TPR price.

Pauper

The Pauper metagame continues to evolve and with it prices keep swinging up and down, although not necessarily accordingly. Familiars, Stompy and Burn are the most popular decks these days. Pauper doesn’t have the impressive price variations and heights of Modern but opportunities are available for speculators willing to closely monitor price fluctuations.

Sunscape Familiar is up nicely but Adaptive Snapjaw is down by 1 tix since the release of MM2. Mono-Black has decreased in popularity and Chittering Rats almost dropped to its all-time floor thus presenting a decent buying opportunity.

Seat of the Synod has also hit a low point this week and is an interesting card to consider for Pauper speculators. Kiln Fiend is now a card to watch as this common crossed the 1 tix bar recently, rising from the being a bulk common.

Targeted Speculative Buying Opportunities

Standard

Monastery Mentor

The Mentor has proven to be a playable creature in pretty much all formats from Standard to Vintage but it hasn't made a splash--yet. Tarkir block cards will soon start rising as we are approaching Standard rotation. We are confident that Monastery Mentor is a good buying opportunity and that it could be in the upper 10s Tix by next October.

Targeted Speculative Selling Opportunities

Modern

Scalding Tarn

Of all the five ZEN fetchlands, Scalding Tarn's growth has been uninterrupted since late April. Its price is now very close to its pre-KTK price. Although Modern events are to come online we think additional growth of the most popular of the ZEN Fetchlands is rather limited and we therefore recommend selling it.

On the other hand, the other ZEN Fetchlands have declined a little bit since the release of MM2 but we think they will have a good chance to rebound with the Modern Festival and the Modern MOCS coming up.

5 thoughts on “Insider: MTGO Market Report for June 17th, 2015

  1. This question is maybe unrelated to this particular article, but I’ve been wondering about it for a while.

    What exactly makes a certain period of time “modern season” or “standard season.” Is it IRL PTQ’s? MTGO PTQs? GPs or PTs? or maybe something else?

    thanks!

    1. A ‘season’ is usually a reference to the PTQ format, but in the past, Standard season could also refer to the time around regional tournaments.

      The shift to the RPTQ and PPTQ system changed this around where stores could offer tournament formats of their choice. But now it has changed again where constructed PPTQs have to match the constructed format of the PT that they feed.

      Loosely speaking, whatever constructed format is the most interesting to the competitive crowd at the moment, that’s the season it is.

      1. I am not good intuitively on this. Can you be more specific? For example: there is modern festival next week, there are standard ptqs online on mtgo right now, there was a modern GP a few days ago, and there is a standard SCG Open this weekend. So what season is it?

        I guess what I’m trying to say is, how do you more definitively decide what the competitive crowd is focusing on, or do you just go with your gut?

        1. Historically Modern season was associated with the PTQs whose format was Modern constructed. It would be about 3 months of all the grinders playing and focusing on a particular format. Thus, Modern season.

          There was also the regional events, which fed the National championships. These were always Standard constructed. Thus, Standard season.

          The switch to PPTQs and RPTQs changed everything, because stores could choose to run whatever format they wanted. No more modern season.

          But, WOTC changed this policy recently. Now, if you want to run a constructed PPTQ, it has to be the same format of the Pro Tour event that it feeds. So, if the Pro Tour has Modern constructed, the constructed PPTQs have to Modern. Thus, Modern season is reborn.

          I’m not really up to speed on the new nationals/regionals/worlds system, so I can’t really comment on how that has changed.

          * * *

          Note, I haven’t mentioned MTGO at all because MTGO follows a totally different rhythm. There is no particular season on MTGO, but the big events with big prizes do drive interest in the relevant format. WOTC has also announced a variety of formats for the online PTQ system, thus, there is no special emphasis on Modern and thus there is no Modern season associated with online PTQS.

          However, paper trends tend to bleed into mtgo, so even if there is no Modern season on MTGO, it matters if there is a Modern season in paper.

          * * *

          I’m sorry if the use of ‘season’ is confusing. Let me reiterate one more though, the use of ‘season’ comes from having a 3 month window where PTQs were all modern Constructed, and so the vast majority of grinders are focusing on Modern during that time.

Join the conversation

Want Prices?

Browse thousands of prices with the first and most comprehensive MTG Finance tool around.


Trader Tools lists both buylist and retail prices for every MTG card, going back a decade.

Quiet Speculation