Insider: What Is the Fate of Legacy?

Are you a Quiet Speculation member?

If not, now is a perfect time to join up! Our powerful tools, breaking-news analysis, and exclusive Discord channel will make sure you stay up to date and ahead of the curve.

First, I want to give a heartfelt thank you to Tyler for covering me last week. I spent a full five nights in the hospital with my wife and newborn. Any attempts at an article would have been poorly thrown together and likely full of content with no value. Now I am home with baby Landon and my wife, and things are slowly stabilizing yet again.

Having a child changes my perspective of many things. I promised myself that one sacrifice I was not willing to make was in Magic. I vowed to maintain this as my only hobby for the next trying year or two. It has grown to be a significant part of who I am, and I couldn’t imagine giving it up.

So with that I begin my next article, still partially inspired by my son.

Many Years Ago – An Anecdote

I still remember the first dual lands I ever purchased. I bought a Kabira Takedown // Kabira Plateau and a Tropical Island for about $12 each.

Sounds like a great deal, right? Well this was back in 1997, so the deal was not as phenomenal as your initial impression. Still, it was an exciting purchase for me because it was the largest Magic purchase I had ever made.

When I got home I was enthusiastic to play with my now most valuable cards! But I quickly realized something. These cards were just lands that produced mana! They wouldn’t bash my opponent for six like Craw Wurm, nor would they deal any direct damage like Delayed Blast Fireball. Worst of all, I had to play a Blue/Green deck or a Red/White deck to even use these cards?! What a poor purchase.

Needless to say, these two cards didn’t remain in my collection for long. (Darn!)

Fast Forward to Today

When my son grows a little older, he will most certainly be exposed to the world of Magic: the Gathering. He has a tremendous advantage in having a father who can guide him along the way. When my friends and I started playing, we had no one to advise us on which cards were powerful and which were most valuable. We believed in the fallacy that Dark Banishing was the ultimate removal spell and Scaled Wurm the ultimate creature. Until, that is, we discovered Lord of the Pit which was immune to the former!

(Chart courtesy of Disclaimer: the writer does not own any Lord of the Pits for investment)

I now realize how powerful and valuable Dual Lands are. Thanks to the Legacy boom largely driven by Star City Games, the Dual Lands have multiplied in value several times. Other staples such as Wasteland and Force of Will have likewise shot up in price.

(Chart courtesy of

I managed to obtain all the Legacy staples I was most interested in shortly before the cards hit their peak. Now I am sitting on a sizable Legacy collection and I have a moral dilemma in front of me.

Now that I have a child there is no way I will be able to get my money’s worth from playing these Legacy cards. I simply cannot play frequently enough nor can I travel to larger events. I have begun to question whether I need to have a collection of Legacy staples at all, since they simply sit in a binder within my closet for months at a time.

Other Factors

While the birth of my son was a primary trigger that causes me to reconsider necessity of my collection, there is an array of other external factors which also drive me to this consideration.

First, I have observed that conversation on The Source, Legacy’s major forum, has dwindled somewhat. There are more posts discussing cards getting stolen, players getting banned and artworks getting altered than there are discussing Legacy strategy. Is this an indicator that focus is shifting away from Legacy?

The second observation I’ve made is that the Star City Games Legacy opens seem to have become uninteresting. When I began playing Legacy there was a vastly diverse metagame. I could play a deck with mostly lands, mostly enchantments, mostly instants/sorceries, or mostly creatures.

Now, it feels like recent printings have warped the format in such a way that diversity is lacking. Cards like Stoneforge Mystic, Jace, the Mind Sculptor, and Batterskull have left a recent scar on Standard and thus leave a sour taste in my mouth when I see them so heavily played in Legacy. It almost feels like Legacy has become Standard with Dual Lands and Force of Will rather than its own unique format.
(Picture courtesy of

The final external factor which causes me to question keeping my Legacy collection lies in the youngest format: Modern.

A light version of Eternal, this format promises a widely diverse format reminiscent of old Legacy. While Legacy feels like a stronger Standard, it’s ironically Modern that fills the void of a diverse Eternal metagame. The result is an immensely popular format – one where I’d prefer to spend my time and money to be honest.

My Options

Legacy is not as alluring as it once was. I, like many, have come to this fateful conclusion. So what should I do with all my cards?

If this were the stock market, this would be a no-brainer. I have made a significant return on my investment in Legacy, and now I feel the card prices have stagnated. I should sell out of these cards and move into something with larger upside, such as Modern.

But emotions do exist and they play a role here. It took me a couple years to assemble my set of 40 Dual Lands – do I want to give them up so quickly? What if Legacy rises in popularity again? Isn’t Underground Sea one of the safest MTG investments one could make?

I could keep only cards for one Legacy deck and sell the rest. But this seems noncommittal to me. I’m in or I’m out – I do not want to straddle the fence here. All it takes is one new card or one banning and the deck I chose could go to the wayside.

Finally, I could sell everything and play a low-budget deck such as Burn. While uninteresting, this option would enable me to play in Legacy tournaments competitively while banking all the profits I’ve made from my initial Legacy investment.

Clearly, I am distraught with this decision. Having all these cards is exhilarating and I love browsing through my binder of Legacy staples. But looking at these cards on occasion simply is not sufficient to motivate me to keep this collection. Opportunity costs here are immense. I could invest in other formats, obtain the holy grail of cards, Black Lotus, or even use the money elsewhere in my life.

I petition the readers for some guidance here. Considering the information I’ve provided above and keeping in mind the context of my current situation, what would you suggest? I would greatly appreciate the suggestions!

8 thoughts on “Insider: What Is the Fate of Legacy?

  1. I'm pretty happy to be sitting on an impressive collection of Legacy cards (I'm probably within 5 cards of almost any deck in the format and I am rarely missing the expensive ones) that I am not even using to play in tournaments. I am however playing them in EDH and other casual formats. I figure if anything these cards are still going to be quite rare in 20 years or so and only getting more valuable. I guess in a way I also like the collecting itself, though I am a player before a collector.

    What I am trying to say is that just storing the cards might not be a bad thing. I figure leaving the decission for later will only gain you more money (though inflation will take part of that) and maybe at some point you do want to pick them up again and then you will be very happy not to have to pay the by then probably much higher prices because you kept them instead. You could even save them to help pay for college for your son later.

    On that note, congratulations!

    1. Thanks, pi! My wife and I are truly blessed to have a healthy, cute baby boy on our hands 🙂

      Your perspective is one I have generally adopted to date. Holding all my Legacy cards (although not as extensive in breadth as yours) has paid off nicely in most cases. But the price curves on many of these cards have stagnated or even corrected. Look at the Force of Will chart as an example. How do we know we haven't reached the final plateau? I believe the market would now need a significant external change in order to alter the card prices significantly. And with the lack of Legacy news lately, this external change seems far off.

      Instant gratification is also a powerful force here. If I sell now, I have cash in hand much sooner 🙂

  2. Short term I think you're right, on the other hand I have plenty of storage space and no immediate need for extra money myself. To me it's more like if I keep them I can keep playing with them if I want to and over time they should become more expensive because of rarity (if just because of copies lost in the trash or to people who stop playing but don't sell). I am happy to sell or trade any extra's though.

    Part of the price of many Legacy cards is EDH, even if Legacy dies down a bit like Vintage, many cards should still remain valuable. Just look at EDH only cards like Capture of Jingzhou, the EDH community will support high-priced cards. In general I feel that even if Legacy goes the way of Vintage, casual players should at least partially keep the prices high. Considering Vintage, those prices haven't really come down either, have they? Just look at what a card with both Vintage and EDH appeal does now: Imperial Seal, which is getting more expensive than Unlimited power (I'm very glad I obtained one just before it shot up). Obviously looking at P3K isn't entirely fair given the rarity, but I think the same applies to lesser cards as well.

    Of course I could not blame you if you do decide to part with them, can certainly see the instant gratification argument and you're bound to need more money when taking care of a little one. For me it would feel more like a loss than gratifying, losing the collection I have spent so much effort, money and time on. Should you want to move some more high-end stuff, like Beta Rares or other high value cards, you could send me a message on the forums, I might be interested (though don't bother for anything in less than EX condition).

    Whatever you decide, good luck!

  3. First off, congrats again.
    I'll give you the same advice I give everyone in this situation — unless you need the money, do not sell. Of course if you need the cash due to the situation at home, it's awesome that Magic was able to fund that. Consider it another gift from this game.
    But if that's not the case, don't sell, especially the duals. Even if you don't play, those cards are going to hold sentimental value for you. Basically every Magic player ever has the story of how they sold their cards X amount of years ago and now wishes they had them when they came back. I tell them if they want to get out to sell most of what they have but keep the things that means the most to them, whether that's a particular deck or set or, in this case, a full set of duals.
    It may seem difficult to spend time in the game now, but one day, even many many years down the road, you could be sitting and playing Magic with your son and wishing you still had those duals. Unless you need the money to support your family, be a little selfish.

  4. I am not in a situation where I need to sell my cards to support my family. This would not be my primary motivation for selling out of Legacy.

    I am trying to draw a parallel here with the stock market. If I bought a stock that shot up rapidly in price and then stagnated, it'd seem like a wise time to sell. You only profit when you sell, after all. To continue holding in anticipation of additional gains seems a bit greedy. If the format ultimately goes the way of Vintage, many cards will likely settle in price. Dual Lands are perhaps safe, but I'd be shocked if EDH was enough to keep Force of Will a $50 card and Lion's Eye Diamond a $40 card. Prices will drop when Legacy inevitably loses popularity. All it takes is one fateful announcement from SCG: "we will start doing Modern on Sundays instead of Legacy on an alternating basis" and people will panic.

  5. I see Legacy going the way of Vintage. A niche format where hardcore players keep their pet decks and play them for fun. I think Modern will very quickly replace Legacy in years to come as a much more accessible format where WOTC has indirect control over the over-inflation of card values.

Join the conversation

Want Prices?

Browse thousands of prices with the first and most comprehensive MTG Finance tool around.

Trader Tools lists both buylist and retail prices for every MTG card, going back a decade.

Quiet Speculation